MHA FPX 5028 Assessment 3 Borrowing a Practice, Not a System example

Reviewed by Rupert Danvers, MBA Comparative Models of Global Health Systems Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MHA FPX 5028 Assessment 3 sample paper draws lessons for US administration by borrowing a practice, not a system: adapting Dutch after-hours primary care cooperatives for a US regional health system. It closes Capella MHA FPX 5028, Comparative Models of Global Health Systems, the MHA course with the catalog code MHA-FPX5028. The paper argues that practices travel more easily than whole systems, describes the Dutch cooperatives, examines what makes them portable and names the national precondition they depend on. It acknowledges resistance honestly, keeps within an administrator's scope, sets out what the regional system would need to build and designs a pilot.

CourseMHA FPX 5028 Comparative Models of Global Health Systems
AssessmentAssessment 3
Paper typeLessons for US practice
LengthAbout 1,070 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramMaster of Health Administration (MHA)
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for MHA FPX 5028 Assessment 3

1

Borrowing a Practice, Not a System: Adapting Dutch After-Hours Primary Care Cooperatives for a US Regional Health System

Student Name

Capella University

MHA FPX 5028: Comparative Models of Global Health Systems

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title makes clear that a practice, not a whole system, is being transferred. Global health papers are judged on whether the lesson can realistically be applied, so the scope is stated.
2

Practices, Not Systems

Health care administrators cannot adopt another country's health system, but they can adopt specific practices that have worked elsewhere. This paper examines one such practice: the after-hours primary care cooperative developed in the Netherlands. The aim is to assess whether a composite US regional health system, here called Heartland Health, with 32 primary care clinics and three hospitals, could adapt the model to reduce avoidable emergency department visits during evenings, nights, and weekends.

The Dutch Practice

In the Netherlands, general practitioners have organized large-scale cooperatives to provide after-hours care for their combined patient populations. Patients who need care outside office hours call a single number, where trained triage nurses, supervised by general practitioners, assess urgency. Many callers receive advice by phone; others are seen at a cooperative center, often located at or near a hospital, or receive home visits. Huibers et al. (2009) compared organizational models of after-hours care in Western countries and described the Dutch cooperative model as one in which a large group of general practitioners shares after-hours duty, allowing each physician to work fewer after-hours shifts. Giesen et al. (2011), reviewing the Dutch experience, reported that after-hours cooperatives achieved high patient satisfaction and generally good quality, while noting concerns about the accuracy of telephone triage in some cases. Transferring a practice rather than a system focuses the analysis on what an administrator can actually change.

What this part is doingThe practice is described with enough detail to judge whether it can be adapted. Scorers reward papers that transfer a specific practice rather than recommending another country's whole system.
3

Portability Examined

The practice has several elements, and each must be examined for portability to Heartland. Centralized telephone triage by nurses using protocols is highly portable. Heartland already operates a nurse advice line, though it is staffed lightly and not connected to after-hours clinical care. Shared after-hours duty among primary care physicians is moderately portable. Heartland's primary care physicians are employed by the system, so it can organize a shared rotation, but physicians may resist added night and weekend duty, as discussed below. Co-location of the after-hours center with the emergency department is portable. Heartland could place an after-hours primary care center next to the emergency department at its largest hospital, allowing emergency staff to redirect patients with primary care needs. Access to patients' records is portable within Heartland, since its clinics share one electronic health record, but not for patients whose primary care is outside the system.

The National Precondition

One feature of the Dutch model depends on a national precondition that the United States lacks. In the Netherlands, residents are registered with a general practitioner, who acts as the gatekeeper to specialist and hospital care, and the after-hours cooperative is the expected route for urgent care outside office hours. In the United States, patients can go directly to emergency departments and have financial incentives that vary by insurance plan. Without registration and gatekeeping, Heartland cannot require patients to call the triage line first. Naming the national precondition identifies which results Heartland should not expect to reproduce. Heartland can encourage use through reminders at every clinic visit, through its patient portal, its clinics, and agreements with payers that waive copayments for after-hours center visits, but it will not see the same concentration of after-hours care as Dutch cooperatives.

Resistance Named Honestly

Three sources of resistance are likely. Primary care physicians already report heavy workloads, and some will see after-hours duty as a burden; the Dutch experience suggests that sharing duty across a large group reduces each physician's load, and Heartland could offer additional pay or use nurse practitioners and physician assistants for some shifts. Emergency physicians may worry that redirecting patients to the after-hours center creates liability if a patient's condition is more serious than it appeared; a clear protocol for medical screening before redirection would address this. The finance department may note that emergency visits generate more revenue than primary care visits under fee-for-service payment; for patients in Heartland's value-based contracts, however, fewer emergency visits reduce costs and improve shared savings.

What this part is doingEach source of resistance is named with a response. Honest discussion of resistance makes the proposal more credible to leaders who will face it.
4

Administrator Scope Respected

The proposal stays within what a health system administrator can decide: organizing Heartland's own physicians and nurses, locating a center, adapting the nurse advice line, and negotiating with payers. It does not propose changes in national law or insurance design. The administrator can, however, share results with state policy makers and payers if the pilot succeeds, which could build support for broader changes that no single health system can make on its own.

What Heartland Would Need to Build

Adapting the model would require several investments. The nurse advice line would need more nurses on evenings and weekends, access to every Heartland patient's record, and protocols aligned with the after-hours center so that callers are directed consistently. The center would need space next to the emergency department, a small laboratory and imaging agreement with the hospital, and a scheduling system that lets triage nurses book patients into open slots. Primary care leaders would need to design the physician rotation with the physicians themselves, since a rotation imposed from above would increase the resistance described earlier. Finally, the health system would need data to track where patients go after calling the triage line, since the value of the model depends on how many calls end in advice, a center visit, or an emergency visit.

Pilot Design

Heartland should pilot the model at its largest hospital for 12 months, with the after-hours center open from 5 p.m. to 11 p.m. on weekdays and 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. on weekends, staffed by a rotation of primary care physicians and advanced practice providers, with the nurse advice line expanded to handle after-hours calls for all 32 clinics. Success would be measured, against the 12 months before the pilot, by the number of low-acuity emergency visits by Heartland primary care patients, patient satisfaction, physician workload, and the rate of patients seen at the center who needed emergency care within 48 hours.

Conclusion

The Dutch after-hours cooperative is a practice that Heartland can adapt, particularly its centralized nurse triage, shared physician duty, and co-location with the emergency department. Its results depend partly on the national precondition of registration and gatekeeping, which the United States lacks, so Heartland should expect smaller effects. A pilot within the administrator's scope can test how much of the Dutch success can be reproduced.

5

References

Giesen, P., Smits, M., Huibers, L., Grol, R., & Wensing, M. (2011). Quality of after-hours primary care in the Netherlands: A narrative review. Annals of Internal Medicine, 155(2), 108-113. https://doi.org/10.7326/0003-4819-155-2-201107190-00006

Huibers, L., Giesen, P., Wensing, M., & Grol, R. (2009). Out-of-hours care in western countries: Assessment of different organizational models. BMC Health Services Research, 9, Article 105. https://doi.org/10.1186/1472-6963-9-105

MHA FPX 5028 Assessment 3 instructions, in plain terms

The final assessment asks you to identify lessons from other health systems that US health care administrators could apply. You carry forward the most instructive trade-off from your comparison, identify specific practices behind it, assess their portability by asking what they depend on, adapt them to a US organization within an administrator's authority, anticipate resistance and propose implementation. Practices, such as a care model or payment approach at organizational level, transfer more readily than national financing systems. The paper should avoid recommending federal policy change as the lesson, because that is outside what an administrator can decide. Evidence on the practice's outcomes supports the proposal.

How this MHA FPX 5028 Assessment 3 example is built

Contrast, candidate practice, portability, application. The opening carries forward the trade-off the comparison identified as most instructive. A candidate block names one or two specific practices that produced it, described concretely enough to be adopted. A portability block asks what each depends on: a financing arrangement, a regulatory power, a cultural expectation, and says which of those exist in the United States. A resistance block names what would obstruct adoption, honestly rather than dismissively. An application block states what an administrator could actually do at organizational level, distinguished from what would require policy change. The closing names what would have to change nationally for the larger version to become possible. Sources support every claim about either system. Foreign practice is sourced from that system's own literature rather than from advocacy about it elsewhere.

Where the marks sit in the MHA FPX 5028 Assessment 3 scoring guide

The scoring guide rates the choice of practice, the portability analysis, the adaptation, the resistance and the implementation plan. The practice reaches Distinguished when described concretely enough to adopt. Portability scores higher when dependencies are named, such as payment arrangements or regulatory powers, with a judgment about which exist in the US. Adaptation earns credit when kept within what an administrator can decide. Resistance should be named honestly, including physician concerns about call coverage. A pilot design with measures shows feasibility. Evidence for outcomes, such as patient satisfaction and emergency department use in the Netherlands, supports the case. Writing and APA are graded.

MHA FPX 5028 Assessment 3 help: mistakes that cost marks

Students often recommend adopting a whole foreign system, which no administrator can do. Another common mistake is ignoring what a practice depends on, so it fails when transplanted. Political language creeps in. Resistance is overlooked. Implementation is vague. Evidence from the source country is not checked for applicability. A pilot, small and measured, is the realistic way to test a borrowed practice, and naming the conditions for scaling it shows judgment. Cost matters as well: estimate what staffing a cooperative would take and who would pay for it under current US payment rules. Physicians' call obligations and malpractice coverage deserve a sentence each.

Get a MHA FPX 5028 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 3 instructions and the MHA FPX 5028 scoring guide from your courseroom, with the profile and comparison your earlier assessments produced. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and separating what an administrator can do from what needs legislation is what makes this application usable. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More MHA FPX 5028 papers and MHA samples

MHA FPX 5028 Assessment 3 questions, answered

What actually transfers between health systems?

Discrete practices more often than structures. Payment arrangements, referral pathways, quality reporting mechanisms and workforce models have all crossed borders in modified form. Financing architecture and entitlement rules rarely do, because they rest on political settlements that took decades and cannot be imported. Settlements do not import.

Should I recommend policy change?

You can identify what would be needed, and keep it separate from what you are recommending. The paper addresses an administrator, so the actionable recommendation has to sit inside an organization's reach. Naming the national precondition afterward shows you understand the boundary rather than ignoring it.

How do I avoid sounding political?

Stay with mechanisms and trade-offs. Describing how a payment arrangement changes provider behavior is administrative; arguing about what people are entitled to is not. The distinction is manageable, and papers that hold it are considerably more persuasive to readers who disagree with the writer. Mechanisms, not entitlements.

Where can I find a free MHA FPX 5028 Assessment 3 sample paper?

This page contains the full paper adapting Dutch after-hours cooperatives for a US regional system, with portability, preconditions, resistance, scope and a pilot design. A custom paper is available free.

What transfers between health systems in MHA FPX 5028 Assessment 3?

Organizational practices, such as care models, scheduling approaches or cooperative arrangements, transfer more easily than national financing. Check what each practice depends on before proposing it.