| Course | NHS FPX 6008 Economics and Decision Making in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Needs analysis for change |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | MSN |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for NHS FPX 6008 Assessment 2
Needs Analysis for Change: A Community Paramedicine Program for Frequent 911 Callers in a Rural County
Student Name
Capella University
NHS FPX 6008: Economics and Decision Making in Health Care
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Introduction
In rural areas, the ambulance is often the most accessible part of the health system. When primary care is far away and home health is limited, people with chronic illness call 911 for problems that could have been prevented or handled at home. This paper analyzes the need for change in one rural county where a small number of residents account for a large share of ambulance calls and emergency visits, and it evaluates a community paramedicine program as a response. The county and its figures are hypothetical and drawn from typical rural data.
The Current State
The county has 38,000 residents, one critical access hospital, and a county-run emergency medical services agency with four ambulances. Last year the agency answered 5,600 calls. Of these, 610 came from 74 residents who called five or more times, most of them older adults with heart failure, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, or diabetes. Many calls ended in transport to the emergency department and discharge home within hours. The agency's medical director estimates that at least half of these calls involved problems that a home visit, a medication adjustment, or a telephone check could have prevented. The cost of the current state is spread among several payers. Each ambulance transport costs the agency about 1,100 dollars to provide, and Medicare and Medicaid reimburse less than that. Each emergency visit costs the hospital more than it recovers for many of these patients. Frequent transports also leave the county with fewer ambulances available for true emergencies, since a crew transporting a patient 30 miles to the hospital is out of service for two hours.
Stakeholders and Their Interests
Five groups hold a stake in any change. Frequent callers want help when they feel unwell and trust the ambulance crews they know. The emergency medical services agency wants to keep ambulances available for emergencies and to reduce unreimbursed transports. The critical access hospital wants fewer avoidable emergency visits but also depends on emergency department revenue. Primary care clinics want to know when their patients are in trouble but lack staff to visit homes. Families of frequent callers, often adult children who live elsewhere, want reassurance that someone is checking on their parent between crises. Payers, including Medicare Advantage and Medicaid managed care plans, want lower total costs. The interests do not all point the same way: the hospital loses some revenue if avoidable visits fall, so its support has to be earned through reduced losses on uninsured visits and through its community benefit obligations.
Options for Change
Three options are available. The first is to do nothing and accept the current costs. The second is to expand home health services, which would require recruiting nurses in a county that already has vacancies. The third is to create a community paramedicine program, in which specially trained paramedics make scheduled home visits to high-risk residents, check vital signs and medications, coordinate with primary care, and respond to non-emergency calls without transport when appropriate. Community paramedicine programs have grown across North America, although they vary widely in design, training, and the services they provide (Chan et al., 2019). Evidence on outcomes is still developing, but some trials are encouraging. In a cluster randomized trial in Ontario, a community paramedicine program offering health promotion and risk assessment to older adults in social housing reduced ambulance calls from the participating buildings compared with control buildings (Agarwal et al., 2018).
Economic Comparison of the Options
Doing nothing costs the agency an estimated 330,000 dollars a year in unreimbursed transports among frequent callers alone, plus the hospital's losses and the harder-to-measure cost of delayed emergency responses. Expanding home health would cost more per visit and depends on staff the county cannot recruit. A community paramedicine program using two paramedics already employed by the agency, working part-time in the new role, would cost about 180,000 dollars a year including training, a vehicle, and supplies. If it reduced frequent-caller transports by a third, a modest target given the trial evidence, the agency would recover most of the program's cost from reduced losses, and the hospital and payers would share additional savings. The comparison favors community paramedicine not because it is cheap, but because it uses a workforce the county already has, in a role the community already trusts, and it can start small and grow with evidence.
The Need the Change Would Meet
The need is not simply fewer ambulance calls. It is a missing layer of care between the clinic and the emergency department for chronically ill residents who live far from both. Community paramedicine would meet that need by bringing assessment and coordination to the home. It would also meet the agency's need to keep ambulances available and the payers' need to reduce avoidable costs.
How the Need Would Be Measured
A needs analysis should state how the need will be recognized as met. Four measures fit this program: the number of 911 calls from enrolled residents in the six months before and after enrollment; emergency department visits and admissions among the same residents; the average time an ambulance is out of service per frequent-caller call; and enrolled residents' ratings of their confidence in managing their conditions at home. Baseline values for the first three already exist in agency and hospital records, which means the program could be evaluated from its first month without new data systems.
Risks and Unknowns
Three risks deserve attention. What paramedics may do is defined in state rules, and some activities, such as medication adjustments, would require protocols approved by the medical director and coordination with primary care. Reimbursement for community paramedicine visits is uncertain; some Medicaid plans pay for them and others do not. And the program's success depends on primary care clinics responding to what paramedics find. The next assessment's business case will address these risks with specific agreements and a funding plan.
Conclusion
The county's frequent 911 callers reflect a gap between primary care and emergency care that falls hardest on chronically ill rural residents and costs every part of the local system. Among the options available, a community paramedicine program best meets the need, uses existing workforce, and offers a credible economic return, provided that scope, reimbursement, and coordination are addressed.
References
Agarwal, G., Angeles, R., Pirrie, M., McLeod, B., Marzanek, F., Parascandalo, J., & Thabane, L. (2018). Evaluation of a community paramedicine health promotion and lifestyle risk assessment program for older adults who live in social housing: A cluster randomized trial. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 190(21), E638-E647.
Chan, J., Griffith, L. E., Costa, A. P., Leyenaar, M. S., & Agarwal, G. (2019). Community paramedicine: A systematic review of program descriptions and training. Canadian Journal of Emergency Medicine, 21(6), 749-761. https://doi.org/10.1017/cem.2019.14
What the NHS FPX 6008 Assessment 2 instructions ask for
The instructions ask you to analyze the need for a change that would address the economic issue from Assessment 1, describing the current situation, the stakeholders and their interests, the options available, the economic implications of each, and the evidence that the change is needed and would work. Many versions ask you to consider the change's effect on quality, access and cost together, and to state the assumptions behind any estimate. Scholarly sources and local data are both expected. The sample runs about 1,080 words with two scholarly sources and local figures. Keep the analysis tied to the same issue and community as Assessment 1, because Assessment 3 turns this analysis into a business case.
How this NHS FPX 6008 Assessment 2 example is built
Need, demand, utilization, barriers, incumbents, gap. A need block establishes what the population requires, from prevalence and clinical evidence rather than from what is currently provided. A demand block reports what is actually sought, which is frequently lower and for reasons worth examining. A utilization block gives what is received. A barriers block names each obstacle between those quantities and sizes it where the data permits. An incumbents block asks who benefits from the current arrangement, since barriers persist for reasons. A gap block states the distance in the economic terms established earlier, so the third assessment has something to build a case on. Assumptions behind every estimate are stated rather than buried in the arithmetic. Need is established from evidence, never from current provision.
Where the marks sit in the NHS FPX 6008 Assessment 2 scoring guide
The scoring guide scores the current state, the stakeholder analysis, the options, the economic comparison, the need and the writing. Stakeholder analysis reaches Distinguished when each group's gains and losses are named, including potential opponents. The options criterion rewards at least two alternatives, one of them the status quo, compared on the same economic terms. The need row scores higher when need is established from evidence rather than from what is currently provided. A measurement plan for the need prepares the business case and earns credit on its own. Risks and unstated assumptions should be surfaced. Writing, sources and APA form are rated too. The comment next to the stakeholder page explains why naming the likely opponent strengthens the analysis.
Common NHS FPX 6008 Assessment 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Students often jump straight to a solution without analyzing need, which turns the paper into a sales pitch. Another loss comes from comparing only one option, the favored one, with nothing. Stakeholder sections that list groups without interests score low. Economic comparisons sometimes use figures with no source or mix time frames. Assumptions buried in the arithmetic make the analysis impossible to check, so state them. Also be careful with national cost estimates; show how they translate to your county. The desk can write a free custom needs analysis for the change you are considering, built on the issue from your own first assessment.
Get a NHS FPX 6008 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 2 instructions and the scoring guide from your NHS FPX 6008 courseroom, plus the issue and community your analysis carries forward. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and keeping need, demand and utilization apart is the move this assessment is built to test. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More NHS FPX 6008 papers and MSN samples
- NHS FPX 6008 Assessment 1: Identifying a Local Health Care Economic Issue
- NHS FPX 6008 Assessment 3: Business Case for Change
- NHS FPX 6008 Assessment 4: Lobbying the Change to a Decision-maker
- NURS FPX 6011 Assessment 2: Evidence-Based Population Health Improvement Plan
- NHS FPX 6004 Assessment 2: Policy Proposal
- NURS FPX 6016 Assessment 2: Quality Improvement Initiative Evaluation
- NHS FPX 5004 Assessment 2: Leadership and Group Collaboration Evaluation
NHS FPX 6008 Assessment 2 questions, answered
Why separate need from demand?
Because collapsing them hides the problem. If you measure need by what people currently seek, a population facing a barrier appears not to need the service at all, which is exactly backwards. Establish need from prevalence and clinical evidence, report demand separately, and the distance between them becomes the thing your analysis is about.
How do I size a barrier?
Find the count affected and the effect on utilization. How many people in the population face a copayment at that level, and what does published evidence say about utilization at that price point. Not every barrier can be sized precisely, but an estimate with its assumptions stated is far more useful than a list where every obstacle appears equally important.
Does it matter who benefits from the current arrangement?
It explains why the problem is still there. Barriers rarely persist through oversight; usually someone saves money, avoids work or retains control because of them. Naming that, without accusation, tells the reader what the change will have to overcome and makes your later business case realistic about the resistance it will meet.
Where can I find a free NHS FPX 6008 Assessment 2 sample paper?
The complete needs analysis for the rural community paramedicine program is on this page, including stakeholders, options, the economic comparison and the measurement plan. A free custom analysis for your own change is available.
What is the difference between need and demand in NHS FPX 6008 Assessment 2?
Need is what a population requires based on evidence; demand is what people actually seek, which is often lower because of cost, access or awareness. Separating them shows where barriers sit and what a change must overcome.