NURS FPX 8004 Assessment 3 Revising in Response to Feedback example

Reviewed by Odette Lachlan, MSN, RN Advanced Doctoral Writing for Nurses Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This NURS FPX 8004 Assessment 3 sample paper revises a doctoral literature review on moral injury among intensive care nurses in response to reviewer feedback. It closes Capella NURS FPX 8004, Advanced Doctoral Writing for Nurses, the DNP course with the catalog code NURS-FPX8004. The paper lists the feedback, maps each comment to the change it produced, answers structural feedback with structural changes, and explains one comment it declined and why. It presents the revised section in full, admits what could not be repaired, shows how the gap statement changed, reports citations checked during revision and reflects on what the writer learned about revising.

CourseNURS FPX 8004 Advanced Doctoral Writing for Nurses
AssessmentAssessment 3
Paper typeRevision with response to feedback
LengthAbout 1,110 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramDNP
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for NURS FPX 8004 Assessment 3

1

Revising a Doctoral Literature Review in Response to Feedback: Moral Injury Among Intensive Care Nurses

Student Name

Capella University

NURS FPX 8004: Advanced Doctoral Writing for Nurses

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title names both the task, revision, and the paper being revised. This assessment is judged on how the writer responds to feedback, so the revision itself is the subject.
2

Introduction

Revision is where doctoral writing improves most, but only when feedback is taken seriously and answered specifically. This paper presents my response to faculty and peer feedback on a draft literature review about moral injury among intensive care nurses, followed by the revised section. The response maps each comment to a change, explains structural revisions, declines one suggestion with reasons, and identifies a limitation that revision could not remove.

The Feedback Received

The draft received five main comments. First, the reviewer noted that I used "moral distress" and "moral injury" interchangeably. Second, the review was organized study by study, which made it read as a list of summaries. Third, several paragraphs made claims without citations. Fourth, a peer suggested adding studies of physicians to strengthen the evidence. Fifth, the reviewer asked for a clearer statement of the gap in the literature that my project would address.

Comment Mapped to Change

Each comment led to a specific change.

CommentChange made
Terms used interchangeablyAdded definitions distinguishing moral distress and moral injury, and used each term consistently
Study-by-study organizationReorganized by theme: definitions, prevalence, contributing factors, consequences, interventions
Unsupported claimsAdded citations or removed claims that could not be supported
Add physician studiesDeclined, with reasons below
Gap unclearAdded a final section stating the gap and how the project addresses it

Structural Feedback Answered Structurally

The most important feedback was structural: the review read as a series of summaries. A cosmetic fix, such as adding transition sentences, would not have solved the problem. I reorganized the entire review by theme. Each theme section now synthesizes several studies, compares their findings, and notes disagreements. Answering structural feedback structurally meant rewriting most of the review rather than editing it, which took longer but changed what the review could argue.

What this part is doingThe revision memo shows that the writer understood the kind of change each comment required. Scorers reward revisions that match the depth of the change to the depth of the feedback.
3

One Comment Declined

A peer suggested adding studies of physicians' moral injury to strengthen the evidence. I considered the suggestion and declined it. My project focuses on intensive care nurses, whose moral injury arises from situations particular to nursing, such as carrying out orders they disagree with and spending long hours at the bedside of dying patients. Studies of physicians address different roles and power relations, and including them would blur the focus. I noted in the revised review that moral injury has been studied in other professions and cited a scoping review that includes them, so that readers know the broader literature exists.

The Revised Section

The following is the revised section on definitions and contributing factors, shown in full. Moral distress and moral injury are related but distinct. Moral distress occurs when a nurse knows the ethically right action but is constrained from taking it. Moral injury is a deeper and more lasting harm that follows when a person perpetrates, fails to prevent, or witnesses acts that violate deeply held moral beliefs, or experiences betrayal by those in authority. A scoping review of moral injury in health care professionals found that the concept, originally developed in studies of military personnel, has been applied to clinicians increasingly since the COVID-19 pandemic, and that definitions vary across studies (Cartolovni et al., 2021). This review uses moral distress for the immediate experience of constraint and moral injury for the lasting psychological harm, following the distinction the scoping review describes. Contributing factors cluster into three groups. The first is clinical situations, especially providing aggressive treatment that nurses believe is not in the patient's interest, and caring for dying patients without adequate time or support. The second is organizational conditions, including staffing shortages that force nurses to leave care undone and a perception that leaders do not listen. The third is individual factors, including experience and personal values. Studies of nurses in high-intensity settings have found high levels of burnout and moral distress, and resilience was associated with lower burnout, suggesting that individual and organizational supports may both matter (Rushton et al., 2015). Organizing contributing factors into groups allows the review to compare studies that measured different factors, rather than summarizing each study's list separately.

What Could Not Be Repaired

One limitation could not be repaired through revision. Most studies of moral injury among nurses are cross-sectional surveys that use different instruments, many of which were developed for other professions or measure moral distress rather than moral injury. This means that prevalence estimates cannot be compared directly and that causal relationships cannot be established. Revision can describe this limitation clearly, which the revised review now does, but it cannot create better studies. The limitation shapes my project: rather than measuring prevalence, it will use interviews to understand how intensive care nurses experience and describe moral injury.

How the Gap Statement Changed

The reviewer's request for a clearer gap led to a new final section. The original draft ended with a summary of findings. The revised section states the gap in one sentence: few studies have examined how intensive care nurses themselves describe moral injury, how it differs from moral distress in their experience, and what they believe would help. It then explains how the interview-based project will address that gap and why the method fits the question. Writing the gap statement forced me to decide what the project would not do, which in turn sharpened the rest of the review.

What this part is doingThe revision shows how one comment reshaped the paper's conclusion and the project that follows. Scorers reward revision memos that trace the effect of feedback beyond the sentence it targeted.
4

Citations Checked During Revision

In adding citations for unsupported claims, I checked each source against the claim it now supports. Two claims in the original draft could not be supported by any source I could find: one stated that most intensive care nurses experience moral injury, and another stated that moral injury causes nurses to leave the profession. I removed the first and rewrote the second to say that moral distress and burnout have been associated with intention to leave, which the evidence does support.

What I Learned About Revision

The revision taught me that feedback often points to a problem larger than the comment suggests. The reviewer's comment about organization was about more than order; it was about whether the review made an argument. I also learned that declining a suggestion is acceptable when the reasons are stated clearly and respectfully.

Conclusion

Revising the literature review in response to feedback produced consistent terminology, a thematic structure that synthesizes rather than summarizes, supported claims, a clear gap, and a considered decision to keep the review focused on nurses. The revision could not overcome limitations in the underlying studies, but it now states them honestly.

5

References

Cartolovni, A., Stolt, M., Scott, P. A., & Suhonen, R. (2021). Moral injury in healthcare professionals: A scoping review and discussion. Nursing Ethics, 28(5), 590-602. https://doi.org/10.1177/0969733020966776

Rushton, C. H., Batcheller, J., Schroeder, K., & Donohue, P. (2015). Burnout and resilience among nurses practicing in high-intensity settings. American Journal of Critical Care, 24(5), 412-420. https://doi.org/10.4037/ajcc2015291

What the NURS FPX 8004 Assessment 3 instructions ask for

The final assessment asks you to revise a piece of your doctoral writing in response to feedback and to explain the revision. You list the feedback received, show what you changed in response to each comment and where, present the revised work, and explain the judgment behind key decisions, including any feedback you chose not to follow. Structural comments should lead to structural changes, not only word edits. The revised piece should be presented in full so the improvement can be judged. Reflection on your revision process shows growth as a scholarly writer. Use the feedback you actually received; a sample can model the response format and depth.

Inside the NURS FPX 8004 Assessment 3 example

Response, revised piece, rationale. A response block lists the feedback received and, against each item, what was changed and where, so the reader is not asked to hunt for the difference. The revised piece follows in full rather than in excerpt, because a revision judged from fragments cannot be judged at all. A rationale block explains the two or three decisions that required judgment, including the comment that was declined and why declining it improved the piece. Where feedback pointed at a weakness the writer could not fully repair, that is stated rather than papered over. The piece ends where it should rather than where the draft ended, and a reader who saw both versions would be able to say what the writer learned.

Reading the NURS FPX 8004 Assessment 3 scoring guide

The scoring guide rates the response to feedback, the quality of the revision, the rationale and the writing. The response reaches Distinguished when each comment is mapped to a specific change and location. Revision quality scores higher when structural feedback produces reorganization. The rationale criterion rewards explaining judgment, including a reasoned decision to decline a comment. Presenting the revised work in full allows the improvement to be judged. Honesty about what could not be fixed earns credit. Doctoral writing standards and APA accuracy apply throughout. The margin notes point to the declined comment and why declining it helped, which is the move that most clearly shows scholarly judgment.

Common NURS FPX 8004 Assessment 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Students often make surface edits in response to structural feedback, which reviewers notice. Another common mistake is a response table that says addressed without showing where. Declining feedback without explanation looks defensive. Presenting fragments of the revision makes it hard to judge. Citations are sometimes not rechecked, even though revision is a good time to catch errors. Reflection that says I learned a lot is too general. Keep the tone of the response professional, even when a comment seems unfair; the reader is judging your judgment as much as your prose. A model response and revision built on your own feedback can be prepared on request.

Get a NURS FPX 8004 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions

Send the Assessment 3 instructions and the scoring guide from your NURS FPX 8004 courseroom, plus the draft and the feedback it received. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and showing which comment produced which change is what makes a revision scoreable at all. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More NURS FPX 8004 papers and DNP samples

NURS FPX 8004 Assessment 3 questions, answered

Do I have to accept every comment?

No, and accepting every one usually costs you. A reviewer comment can rest on a misreading, and a writer who explains why the original was right, in terms that engage the substance rather than defending the wording, demonstrates exactly the judgment the assessment is looking for. Decline something, once, and defend it properly.

What counts as answering structural feedback?

Changing the structure. If a comment says the argument is missing, the revision needs an argument, not a stronger topic sentence in the paragraph where the argument should have been. Sentence-level edits in response to paragraph-level problems are the most common reason a revision reads as cosmetic to whoever gave the feedback.

Should the revision be shorter than the draft?

Usually, yes. Most drafts at this stage carry material that survived because it was written rather than because it was needed. A revision that grows in every section rarely reflects the feedback, and control of length is scored here. Cutting a paragraph you liked is often the clearest evidence that the revision was real.

Where can I find a free NURS FPX 8004 Assessment 3 sample paper?

This page holds the full revision of the moral injury literature review, with the feedback map, structural changes, the declined comment, the revised section and reflection. A free custom model is available.

Do I have to accept every comment in NURS FPX 8004 Assessment 3?

No. You may decline a comment if you explain why the change would weaken the work. Reviewers respect a reasoned decision more than a change made only to comply.