| Course | PHI FPX 3200 Ethics in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 1 |
| Paper type | Ethical case analysis |
| Length | About 1,150 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | Undergraduate health care core |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 1
Refusing the Tube: Autonomy and Beneficence for a 24-Year-Old With Severe Anorexia Nervosa, Decided on Capacity, Priced in Trust, and Routed Through Psychiatry, Ethics, and the Law
Student Name
Capella University
PHI FPX 3200: Ethics in Health Care
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Clinical Facts
Hannah Brooks is a 24-year-old graduate student, a composite patient, brought to the hospital after she fainted at a campus gym and was then moved to a medical floor. She has had anorexia nervosa, restricting type, for six years, with two earlier admissions to an eating disorder program. On admission she weighs 36 kilograms at a height of 166 centimeters, a body mass index of about 13.1. Her resting heart rate is 38 beats per minute, she has orthostatic dizziness, and her potassium and phosphate are at the low end of normal before any feeding has begun, which places her at high risk of refeeding syndrome. The medical team recommends continuous nasogastric feeding started slowly, with electrolyte replacement and cardiac monitoring. Hannah agrees to cardiac monitoring and to eat meals on a supervised plan, but refuses the nasogastric tube. She says the tube is "the thing I cannot live through again" and that she will eat enough on her own. Her parents, who drove in overnight, ask the team to place the tube regardless. Hannah is an adult and has not given permission for the team to share details with them beyond the fact of her admission. The unresolved question is not what is medically best, which is agreed, but whether her refusal should be honored.
Both Principles Given Real Standing
Respect for autonomy makes a serious claim here. Hannah is an adult, she is articulate, and her refusal is not a refusal of all treatment. She has accepted monitoring and an oral meal plan, which is a reasoned counteroffer rather than a rejection of care. Beauchamp and Childress (2019) describe autonomous choice as action taken intentionally, with understanding, and without controlling influences, and they warn that clinicians too readily read disagreement as incapacity. Overriding a competent adult's refusal of an invasive procedure is a grave act, and nasogastric feeding against resistance can require restraint. Beneficence and nonmaleficence make an equally serious claim. A heart rate of 38 at this weight signals cardiac risk that can end in sudden death, and anorexia nervosa carries one of the highest mortality rates of any psychiatric illness. Oral intake alone may not reach the calories needed quickly enough, and a failed oral plan loses days the patient may not have. The team's duty to prevent a preventable death is not paternalism for its own sake; it is the ordinary obligation of clinicians toward a patient at imminent risk. Neither principle is a straw figure in this case, which is what makes it a dilemma rather than a mistake.
Priority Argued From the Specifics
The conflict is settled by capacity, and capacity is specific to this decision. Appelbaum (2007) sets out four abilities that a capacity evaluation tests: whether the patient can state a choice, whether she grasps the facts she has been told, whether she accepts that those facts are true of her own case, and whether she can weigh the options against one another. In the consultation liaison psychiatrist's evaluation, Hannah communicated a stable choice and repeated the risks accurately, including that her heart rate could lead to cardiac arrest. Her reasoning between options was coherent. Her appreciation was not intact: asked whether the risk of dying applied to her, she said that other patients die but she is "not sick enough for that," and she described her current weight as higher than it should be. That finding matters for a specific reason. Tan et al. (2006) interviewed patients with anorexia nervosa and found that many could understand and reason about treatment while the illness shaped the values they applied, such as the importance of not gaining weight, in ways the patients themselves sometimes recognized as the disorder speaking. Hannah's refusal is not a stable preference formed apart from the illness; it is built around the one outcome the illness most distorts. Her capacity for this decision is impaired, although her capacity for many other decisions, such as which meals to eat or whom to inform, is not. The priority therefore goes to beneficence, but narrowly. Because her counteroffer is reasonable, the team offers a 48-hour supervised oral trial with thresholds written in advance: intake of at least the prescribed calories at each meal, stable electrolytes, and a heart rate that does not fall further. If the thresholds are met, the tube is not placed.
The Cost of the Resolution Stated
The resolution has costs, and they fall on Hannah. If the thresholds are missed, a tube may be placed over her objection, possibly with sedation or restraint, which infringes her bodily integrity and repeats the experience she named as unbearable. Her trust in the team, which future outpatient treatment depends on, may be damaged for years. Her parents may also read the decision as permission to be involved in ways she has refused. These costs are not reasons to reverse the priority, but they are reasons to minimize coercion, to explain each step to her in advance, and to keep her information private unless she agrees otherwise. The opposite resolution would have costs of its own, and they belong in the same account. Honoring the refusal without conditions would leave Hannah on an oral plan she has not managed to follow in six years of illness, with a heart rate already low enough to stop. If she died or suffered a cardiac arrest, the team would have respected a choice that the illness itself had shaped. That cost would fall on Hannah as well, and it could not be repaired later, while damaged trust sometimes can.
A Decision Routed Through Process
No single clinician should make this decision alone. The process is as follows. First, the psychiatrist's capacity assessment is documented with the specific findings on appreciation, and repeated if her condition changes. Second, the ethics consultation service reviews the plan within 24 hours and meets with Hannah. Third, if feeding over objection becomes necessary, the hospital uses the legal route its state provides, such as involuntary psychiatric treatment or an emergency court order, rather than informal pressure. Fourth, the team revisits the decision daily, and Hannah's choices are honored in every area where her capacity is intact.
Conclusion
Hannah's case sets a genuine claim of autonomy against a genuine duty to prevent death. The deciding fact is that her appreciation of her own risk is impaired by the illness at the center of the choice. Beneficence governs, through the least restrictive step first, with its costs to her trust and bodily integrity stated and reduced, and with the decision carried by a documented process rather than by one person's judgment.
References
Appelbaum, P. S. (2007). Assessment of patients' competence to consent to treatment. New England Journal of Medicine, 357(18), 1834-1840. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMcp074045
Beauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F. (2019). Principles of biomedical ethics (8th ed.). Oxford University Press.
Tan, J. O. A., Stewart, A., Fitzpatrick, R., & Hope, R. A. (2006). Competence to make treatment decisions in anorexia nervosa: Thinking processes and values. Philosophy, Psychiatry, & Psychology, 13(4), 267-282. https://doi.org/10.1353/ppp.2007.0032
PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 1 instructions, in plain terms
The first assessment in PHI FPX 3200 asks you to analyze an ethical dilemma in a health care case using ethical principles or theories. You describe the case facts neutrally, identify the principles in conflict, such as autonomy and beneficence, apply them to the specifics, argue for a resolution, state its costs and explain the process by which the decision should be made. The case may be provided in the courseroom or chosen by you, with identifying details removed. Sources include bioethics texts such as Beauchamp and Childress, professional codes and case law where relevant. The analysis should reach a decision rather than list considerations. Capacity is often central, since a patient with capacity can refuse treatment even when others disagree.
How this PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 1 example is built
The example moves from facts to principles to a defended decision. The opening section lays out the clinical situation in neutral language, separating what is known from what is contested, because a dilemma misdescribed is a dilemma dodged. The second section identifies the principles in play and shows each one applying: what autonomy demands here, what beneficence or nonmaleficence demands instead, with the conflict stated as real rather than apparent. The third section is the adjudication, where the clinical details do the arguing: capacity, information, pressure, prognosis. The fourth states the resolution, defends it against the strongest rival reading, and accounts for the cost to the principle that lost. A closing process section places the decision inside a mechanism, a documented conversation, an ethics consult, so the conclusion could actually happen in a hospital.
PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 1 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
The criteria cover the case description, the identification of principles, the application, the resolution, the costs and the decision process. The case reaches Distinguished when facts are stated neutrally, with what is known separated from what is disputed. Principles score higher when both sides are given real weight rather than one being set up to lose. Application earns credit when priority is argued from the details, such as the patient's decision-making capacity and the medical risk. The resolution should be clear and defended. Stating its costs, such as damage to trust or risk to life, shows honesty. A fair process, involving psychiatry, the ethics committee and legal review where needed, shows how the decision should actually be made in a hospital.
Common PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Students often describe the case with language that already takes a side, which weakens the analysis before it begins. Another common mistake is naming principles without applying them to the facts. One principle is treated as a straw man. The resolution is left open, with a conclusion that says both sides have merit. Capacity is assumed rather than assessed, although it decides much of the case. Costs of the chosen path are ignored. The decision process is missing, so the paper does not say who decides. Using Beauchamp and Childress's principles with specific facts from the case, and stating what the resolution gives up, produces a strong analysis.
Get a PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions
Attach the Assessment 1 instructions and scoring guide from your PHI FPX 3200 courseroom, together with the case your section presents. The custom example is written to those criteria with the principles adjudicated on the clinical specifics, and it reaches you in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample carries no charge. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More PHI FPX 3200 papers and Undergraduate health care core samples
- PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 2: Policy Ethics Analysis
- PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 3: Position Defense Paper
- BHA FPX 2002 Assessment 1: Historical Analysis
- BHA FPX 2003 Assessment 1: Trend Identification Paper
- BHA FPX 2006 Assessment 1: Regulatory Analysis
- BHA FPX 4104 Assessment 1: Workforce Needs Analysis
PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 1 questions, answered
Which principles usually collide in PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 1 cases?
Autonomy against beneficence is the classic pairing, a patient refusing treatment the clinical team believes will help, but current courserooms also run nonmaleficence against beneficence in aggressive-intervention cases and justice against autonomy where resources or family burdens enter. Work with the pair your case actually raises, and resist adding principles that have no real claim on the facts.
Does the analysis have to reach a single decision?
In most sections yes, and the decision needs a defense rather than just a statement. What the criteria reward is a resolution argued from the case's specifics, tested against its strongest rival, and honest about its cost. A paper that presents both sides and stops has done the setup for this assessment without doing the assessment itself.
How much clinical detail should the case summary keep?
Everything the ethical reasoning will later lean on: prognosis, the capacity evaluation, what the patient was told, who holds decision authority and what pressure exists in the room. Detail that never returns in the analysis is padding, and detail that is missing when the adjudication needs it forces the paper to argue from assumptions. Let the reasoning decide what the summary keeps.
Where can I find a free PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 1 sample paper?
This page contains the full ethical case analysis on feeding tube refusal in severe anorexia nervosa, with neutral facts, both principles weighed, a defended resolution, its costs and the decision process. A model analysis of your own case can be requested free.
Which ethical principles should PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 1 use?
Beauchamp and Childress's four principles are the standard lens for this paper. Apply the two or three in real conflict in your case rather than defining all four.