PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 3 position defense paper example

Reviewed by Sadie Mortlake, MA Ethics in Health Care Capella University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 3 sample paper defends an ethical position on who decides when no one is there: committee review of a tracheostomy decision for an unrepresented older man, against the attending physician deciding alone. It closes Capella PHI FPX 3200, Ethics in Health Care, catalog code PHI-FPX3200. The paper states the case and the resolution in a sentence a clinician could act on, anchors its reasons in principles, and answers the rival resolution fairly. It keeps a ledger of what the position sacrifices, such as time and physician autonomy, and names the conditions that would flip the verdict.

CoursePHI FPX 3200 Ethics in Health Care
AssessmentAssessment 3
Paper typeEthical position defense
LengthAbout 1,090 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolCapella University
ProgramUndergraduate health care core
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 3

1

Who Decides When No One Is There: Defending Committee Review for a Tracheostomy Decision for an Unrepresented Older Man, Against the Attending Physician Deciding Alone

Student Name

Capella University

PHI FPX 3200: Ethics in Health Care

Instructor Name

Month Day, Year

What this part is doingThe title states the position and its rival. Position papers are judged on commitment and fairness to the other side, so both appear.
2

The Case and the Resolution

Walter Kaminski, a composite patient, is a 79-year-old retired machinist admitted to the intensive care unit with pneumonia and respiratory failure after a stroke. He has been on a ventilator for 12 days and has failed two trials of breathing on his own. He cannot communicate reliably. He has no advance directive, no spouse, no children, and no contact with his one brother, who died last year. His landlord, the only person who visited, knows him but has no legal authority and does not know his wishes. The team must decide whether to place a tracheostomy and feeding tube, which would likely mean months in a long-term acute care hospital, or to move toward comfort care. Walter is what the literature calls an unrepresented patient. My position is this: for a major decision such as this one, the choice should be made by a multidisciplinary review panel that includes a physician not involved in his care, a nurse, a social worker, and a community member or ethics consultant, reaching a written decision based on his known values and best interests, with the attending physician presenting the case but not deciding alone. The panel would work in a set order. The social worker searches for relatives and friends and interviews anyone who knew Walter. The attending physician presents the prognosis with and without the tracheostomy, including the likely quality of life in long-term care. The panel first applies substituted judgment, asking what Walter would have chosen based on the evidence of his values. Only where that evidence is too thin does it fall back on his best interests. Its written decision names the members, the evidence considered, and the reasons, and it goes into the medical record.

What this part is doingThe resolution is stated so a hospital could act on it. Scorers reward positions phrased as what should actually happen.
3

Reasons Anchored in Principle Work

The first reason comes from respect for autonomy, even in its absence. Walter cannot choose, but he had values, and those values should shape the decision as far as they can be known. A panel with a social worker is more likely to gather what evidence exists: the landlord's account that Walter often said he "never wanted to live hooked to machines like his father did," his refusal of a colonoscopy two years earlier, and his long independence. One physician under time pressure is less likely to search for these facts. The second reason comes from nonmaleficence and the risk of bias. Pope (2013) notes that unrepresented patients are often among the most vulnerable in the hospital and that decisions made by the treating physician alone lack any outside check. The treating team may lean toward aggressive treatment from habit, or toward limiting treatment because of bed pressure or assumptions about an isolated, older man. Neither tendency is visible from inside one person's judgment. The third reason comes from justice. The American Geriatrics Society recommends that decisions for unrepresented older adults use a process with safeguards, including review by people not involved in the patient's care, rather than leaving the choice to the attending physician (Dixon et al., 2025). Patients who have family receive the attention of someone who knows them; a panel is the nearest equivalent the hospital can offer those who do not. A patient with no one to speak for him should not also be a patient no one outside the team ever reviews.

The Rival Resolution Answered Fairly

The strongest rival is that the attending physician, with a second physician's concurrence, should decide. This position protects real values. The attending knows the patient's condition best, can act quickly, and carries clear professional responsibility. A panel may slow a time-sensitive decision, and committee decisions can spread responsibility so thinly that no one owns the outcome. Many hospitals already use this two-physician model. The rival still loses in Walter's case. The tracheostomy decision is not an emergency; he is stable on the ventilator, and a panel can meet within 48 hours. A second physician, usually a colleague on the same service, shares the team's assumptions and is not positioned to gather evidence about Walter's values. Responsibility is not lost in the panel model, because the panel issues a written decision with named members and reasons.

What this part is doingThe rival is presented at full strength and the value it protects is named before it is answered.
4

A Ledger of What the Position Sacrifices

The position has costs. It gives up speed: a panel adds up to two days of ventilation, with its own small risks. Every extra day on the ventilator carries some chance of a new infection. It gives up some clinical authority, because the attending's judgment becomes one voice among several. It adds staff time, perhaps six hours of combined time for each case, in a hospital with limited ethics resources. It accepts that a panel could disagree with the treating team and that the team must then carry out a plan it did not choose. It also depends on hearsay evidence, since the landlord's account cannot be verified. There is a further risk that the panel becomes a formality. If it meets only to approve what the team has already decided, it adds delay without adding protection, and the hospital must accept the cost of training members and auditing a sample of decisions to prevent that. These costs are real, but they buy an outside check on the most serious decision the hospital makes for a person who has no other protection.

Conditions That Would Flip the Verdict

The position would change under certain conditions. If the decision were an emergency, such as whether to intubate during a sudden decline, the attending should act immediately and the panel should review afterward. If a legal surrogate appeared, such as a court-appointed guardian or a relative found by the social worker, that person should decide. If the hospital could not assemble a panel within a few days, delay itself would become a harm, and the two-physician model would be the better choice.

Conclusion

For Walter, the panel reviewed the landlord's account and his earlier refusals, found clear evidence that he would not want prolonged dependence on machines, and recommended comfort-focused care, which the attending accepted. The position is defended because it best respects his values, guards against bias, and gives an unrepresented patient a review that others receive from family, at a cost in time and authority that the case can afford.

5

References

Dixon, J. D., Josyula, A. V., Javier, N. M., Zweig, Y., Singh, M., Kim, L., Thothala, N., & Farrell, T. W. (2025). American Geriatrics Society position statement: Making medical treatment decisions for unrepresented older adults. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 73(5), 1353-1364. https://doi.org/10.1111/jgs.19288

Pope, T. M. (2013). Making medical decisions for patients without surrogates. New England Journal of Medicine, 369(21), 1976-1978. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMp1308197

PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 3 instructions, in plain terms

The final assessment asks you to take and defend a position on an ethical question in health care. You state the case and your resolution, give reasons grounded in ethical principles and the facts, present the strongest opposing position fairly and answer it, acknowledge what your position costs and state the conditions under which you would change your view. Unrepresented patients, end-of-life decisions, resource limits and conscientious objection are common topics. Sources include bioethics literature, professional guidelines such as the American Geriatrics Society position on unrepresented patients and relevant law. The paper should commit to a position while treating the opposing view with respect.

Inside the PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 3 example

The example runs commitment first, defense second, ledger third. The opening states the resolution in a sentence a clinician could act on and previews the reasons. The defense section then argues those reasons from the case or policy specifics, each anchored in the principle analysis rather than in sentiment, and cites where the claims lean on clinical or ethics literature. The rival section reconstructs the resolution the writer rejected at its strongest, including the value it protects better, and answers it on the merits. The sacrifice ledger follows as its own section, listing what the chosen position costs and who feels it, without softening language. A conditions paragraph sets out the circumstances under which this resolution would no longer hold. The close returns to the position with its costs still visible, which this course reads as confidence rather than hedging.

Where the marks sit in the PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 3 scoring guide

The scoring guide rates the position, the reasons, the counterargument, the acknowledgment of costs and the conditions for change. The position reaches Distinguished when stated in a sentence a clinician could act on. Reasons score higher when anchored in principles and the specifics of the case. The counterargument earns credit when the rival position is stated at full strength and answered. A ledger of what the position sacrifices shows ethical maturity. Conditions that would flip the verdict show openness to evidence. Clear writing and accurate citations complete the rubric, and the verdict should be stated again in the conclusion so the reader leaves with it.

PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 3 help from the desk

Students often state a position vaguely, which makes it impossible to defend or challenge. Another common mistake is presenting the opposing view weakly. Reasons rely on general principles without the case facts. Costs of the position are hidden. The paper never says what would change the author's mind. Sources are limited to one textbook. Writing the position first, then the best case against it, keeps the defense honest and persuasive. Check the law in your state, since some states specify who may consent for unrepresented patients. Remember that the patient's known values, even without a surrogate, should shape the decision, so describe what is known about them. Time matters too: a process that takes weeks may harm a patient on a ventilator.

Get a PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions

Send over the Assessment 3 instructions and scoring guide from your PHI FPX 3200 courseroom, along with the case or policy question your position must resolve. The custom example arrives within 24 to 48 hours, written to those criteria with the rival answered and the costs on the page. The first custom sample is free of charge. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.

More PHI FPX 3200 papers and Undergraduate health care core samples

PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 3 questions, answered

Can my position disagree with what actually happened in the case?

Yes, where the case comes from your experience or from published material with a known outcome. The assessment scores the defense, not the match with events, and arguing that the real decision was wrong often produces a sharper paper because the rival position arrives ready-made. Keep identifiers out and treat the actual outcome as the rival to answer.

How is this defense different from the earlier case analysis?

The first assessment weighs two principles and argues a priority; this one commits to a full resolution and holds it against pressure. The center of gravity moves from adjudication to accountability: the paper must answer its strongest rival and price its own sacrifices. In many sections the earlier analysis supplies the raw material, and this paper decides what to do with it.

Is naming what my position sacrifices going to weaken my grade?

The opposite, in current courserooms. Scoring guides at this level reserve their upper bands for work that demonstrates judgment, and judgment shows most clearly in a writer who commits while counting the cost. A defense that admits what it gives up is harder to attack, easier to trust, and visibly distinct from the sermon-shaped papers this assessment attracts.

Where can I find a free PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 3 sample paper?

This page contains the full position defense on committee review for an unrepresented patient's tracheostomy decision, with reasons, the rival view, costs and conditions for change. A model defense of your own position can be requested free.

Who decides for an unrepresented patient in PHI FPX 3200 Assessment 3?

It depends on state law and hospital policy. Options include the attending physician, a second physician, an ethics committee or a court-appointed guardian, and the paper should argue which is most fair.