| Course | PM FPX 4070 Procurement Management in Project Management |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 1 |
| Paper type | Make-or-buy analysis |
| Length | About 1,110 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Business, Project Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for PM FPX 4070 Assessment 1
Make or Buy for a Veterinary Hospital's Network and Phones: One Component, Both Columns Built From the Same Elements, Hidden Internal Costs Counted, Factors Money Cannot Express, and a Recommendation With a Reversal Condition
Student Name
Capella University
PM FPX 4070: Procurement Management in Project Management
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
One Component, Not the Whole Project
The analysis covers one component of Maple Ridge Animal Hospital's relocation: the network cabling, wireless system, phone system, and workstation setup in the renovated Prairie Road building. Other components, such as construction and clinical equipment, are clearly bought and are not part of this analysis. The question arose because the practice employs a part-time IT coordinator, Tyler Grant, who maintains the current network at Elm Street and has offered to do the installation himself with contractors hired by the hour, saving the IT vendor's margin.
Both Columns Built From the Same Elements
Each option is costed using the same eight elements, so the comparison is fair. Cabling materials and installation: make, hire a licensed low-voltage electrician by the hour, estimated 24,000 dollars including materials; buy, included in the vendor's quote of 38,000 dollars. Network equipment, switches, firewall, and wireless access points: make, purchased directly, 14,500 dollars; buy, included in the vendor's quote above. Phone system: make, purchased directly with cloud service, 16,000 dollars including handsets and the first year; buy, vendor quote 22,000 dollars. Workstation moves and setup: make, done by Tyler; buy, vendor quote 30,000 dollars, which includes new cabling at each workstation, imaging, and testing. Internal labor: make, Tyler's time, estimated 180 hours at a loaded rate of 42 dollars, 7,560 dollars; buy, about 30 hours of Tyler's time for coordination, 1,260 dollars. Project manager coordination: make, about 40 hours at 55 dollars, 2,200 dollars; buy, about 12 hours, 660 dollars. Testing and documentation: make, Tyler and the electrician, about 20 hours, included above plus 800 dollars for a coverage survey tool rental; buy, included in the vendor's quote with a written coverage report. Warranty and support in the first 90 days: make, Tyler's time and vendors' product warranties only; buy, the vendor's 90-day workmanship warranty and support included. Totals: make, about 65,060 dollars plus uncosted risk; buy, about 91,920 dollars.
Hidden Internal Costs Counted
The make option's apparent savings of about 27,000 dollars shrink when hidden costs are counted. Tyler works 20 hours a week and is the only person who supports the practice's current systems; 180 hours on the installation over about six weeks would mean either paying him for extra hours or leaving Elm Street systems with little support during the busiest weeks before the move. Paying extra hours is counted above; the cost of reduced support is not. If the installation slips, the practice has no one to hold accountable except its own employee. Kerzner (2017) observes that internal resources are often costed at their direct pay while their opportunity cost, the work they are not doing, goes unrecorded. Tyler's hours on the installation are hours he is not spending keeping the current clinic running.
Factors Money Cannot Express
Some factors cannot be priced. Schedule risk: the network installation is on the critical path, and a vendor with two technicians and experience with clinic moves is more likely to finish in three weeks than one part-time employee with an hourly electrician. Accountability: the vendor's fixed price and warranty place responsibility for defects on the vendor. Knowledge: if Tyler installs the system, he will know it thoroughly, which helps later support. Relationship: Tyler has offered to do the work and may feel undervalued if the practice chooses a vendor; involving him as the practice's technical reviewer of the vendor's work addresses this.
Recommendation With a Reversal Condition
Recommendation: buy. Contract with the IT vendor for cabling, network, phones, and workstation setup at about 90,000 dollars, with Tyler as the practice's technical reviewer. The main reasons are that the work is on the critical path, that the practice's only IT employee cannot take on 180 hours without weakening support for the current clinic, and that a fixed price with warranty transfers risk the practice cannot easily carry. Reversal condition: if the vendor's price rises above 100,000 dollars after the site survey, or if the vendor cannot commit two technicians for the scheduled three weeks, the practice will reconsider the make option, with Tyler's hours temporarily increased and a second electrician hired to protect the schedule. A recommendation with a reversal condition tells the sponsor exactly what new fact would change the answer.
How the Figures Were Obtained
The make figures come from a quote by a licensed low-voltage electrician for cabling labor and materials, list prices for the network equipment and phones Tyler selected, and Tyler's own estimate of his hours, which the project manager increased by 20% because first-time installers usually underestimate. The buy figures come from the IT vendor's written quote against the draft statement of work, after a site walk with the architect's drawings. Using quotes on both sides keeps the comparison from pitting a real price against a hopeful estimate.
Sensitivity of the Comparison
The comparison is sensitive to Tyler's hours. If his 180 hours became 260, which is plausible for someone doing a first full installation, the make option's internal labor would rise to about 10,900 dollars and the gap would shrink to about 23,500 dollars. If a schedule slip of one week on the critical path occurred because of the make option, the added contractor overhead of about 3,000 dollars and the risk to the opening date would narrow the difference further. The buy option's figure, by contrast, is fixed unless scope changes.
Tyler's Role Under the Buy Option
Under the buy option, Tyler reviews the vendor's network design before installation, witnesses the cabling certification tests, and receives the configuration backups and credentials. This keeps his knowledge of the new system strong for future support, recognizes his expertise, and gives the practice an informed reviewer who works for it rather than for the vendor.
What the Analysis Assumes
It assumes Tyler's loaded rate of 42 dollars and the electrician's hourly rate hold through the installation weeks; that the vendor's quote includes everything in the scope statement; and that the phone system chosen is the same in both options.
Conclusion
Built from the same eight elements, the make option looks about 27,000 dollars cheaper, but hidden costs in reduced support and schedule risk narrow the gap, and unpriced factors favor the vendor. The practice should buy, with its IT coordinator as reviewer, unless the vendor's price exceeds 100,000 dollars or it cannot commit the needed technicians.
References
Kerzner, H. (2017). Project management: A systems approach to planning, scheduling, and controlling (12th ed.). Wiley.
The Capella PM FPX 4070 Assessment 1 instructions
The first assessment in PM FPX 4070 asks you to decide whether a project should produce a component itself or buy it. You choose one component, state its requirement, estimate the full cost of making it, including internal labor, tools, overhead and the opportunity cost of staff time, estimate the full cost of buying it, including the price, management effort and transition, compare the two on the same basis, consider qualitative factors such as control, expertise and support, and make a recommendation. Procurement management texts and the PMBOK Guide's discussion of make-or-buy decisions support the analysis. Cost figures should have a stated source.
How this PM FPX 4070 Assessment 1 example is built
The example decides the scope before it decides anything else. It opens by naming the single component under analysis, because a make-or-buy argument applied to a whole project collapses into generalities. The second block sets the requirement: what the component has to do, to what standard, by when. The third block builds the internal case with its cost elements and its assumptions listed. The fourth block builds the external case on the same elements, so the two columns can be compared line by line rather than headline to headline. The fifth block brings in the factors that are not costs, and weights them openly. The sixth states the recommendation, ties it back to both the numbers and the weighting, and names the condition under which the answer would flip. A short sensitivity note closes it, since one assumption usually carries the result.
Reading the PM FPX 4070 Assessment 1 scoring guide
Capella's scoring guide rates the scope, the requirement, the cost comparison, the hidden costs, the qualitative factors and the recommendation. Scope reaches Distinguished when limited to one component, since a whole-project make-or-buy decision becomes too general. The comparison scores higher when both columns use the same cost elements. Hidden costs earn credit when internal labor, learning time and ongoing support are counted for the make option. Qualitative factors are judged on whether they are weighed with the numbers, such as who fixes the phones at midnight. The recommendation should include a reversal condition. Sensitivity shows how close the decision is. Proficient analyses compare prices; Distinguished ones compare full costs and name what would change the answer.
PM FPX 4070 Assessment 1 help: mistakes that cost marks
Make-or-buy papers often compare a vendor's price with only the materials cost of doing it in-house, which makes making look far cheaper than it is. Another weakness is analyzing the entire project instead of a single component. The two columns use different elements, so the comparison is uneven. Staff time is treated as free because salaries are already paid. Qualitative factors are listed but not weighed. The recommendation has no condition that would reverse it. Building one table with identical rows for make and buy, then adding a short paragraph on the factors money cannot capture, keeps the analysis fair and prepares the statement of work in Assessment 2.
Get a PM FPX 4070 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions
Forward the Assessment 1 instructions and the scoring guide out of your PM FPX 4070 courseroom, plus the project scenario and the component the decision covers. We write a custom example to those criteria, with matching cost columns, stated assumptions and a recommendation that follows the numbers, and return it in 24 to 48 hours. First one free. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More PM FPX 4070 papers and BS in Business, Project Management samples
- PM FPX 4070 Assessment 2: Statement of Work
- PM FPX 4070 Assessment 3: Procurement Plan
- PM FPX 4080 Assessment 1: Product Backlog
- PM FPX 4060 Assessment 1: Risk Identification Memo
- PM FPX 1000 Assessment 1: Project Selection Memo
- PM FPX 4050 Assessment 1: Stakeholder Analysis
PM FPX 4070 Assessment 1 questions, answered
Where do I get cost figures if the scenario does not supply them?
Build them from stated assumptions and say so. A labor rate, an hours estimate, a license cost and a vendor quote range are all defensible when the source or the assumption behind each is printed next to the figure. Where published rates exist from professional bodies or public procurement records, cite them. Faculty are grading the reasoning, not auditing the arithmetic.
Can the answer be to build when buying is cheaper?
Yes, and it often makes the stronger paper. Retaining a capability the organization considers core, protecting confidential data, or keeping the knowledge inside the team can outweigh a price difference. What the criterion wants is the tradeoff argued openly: state the premium, say what it purchases, and show that the decision was made rather than assumed.
How does this differ from the later procurement assessments?
This one decides whether the project buys at all. The statement of work then specifies exactly what a supplier delivers, and the procurement plan sets contract type, selection and oversight. Reusing the same content across all three loses criteria in each, because the deliverables answer different questions and in many sections the scoring guides share almost no language.
Where can I find a free PM FPX 4070 Assessment 1 sample paper?
A full make-or-buy analysis of the hospital's network and phones is available on this page, with both columns built from the same elements, hidden internal costs counted and a recommendation with a reversal condition.
Are internal staff costs real in PM FPX 4070 Assessment 1?
Yes. Staff already on payroll still cost money, and time spent on this component is time not spent on other work. The analysis counts that opportunity cost.