| Course | PM FPX 5018 Project Management Foundations |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Methodology comparison |
| Length | About 1,100 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | MS in Project Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for PM FPX 5018 Assessment 2
Choosing an Approach for an Online Claims Intake Project: Criteria Drawn From the Organization, Both Approaches at Equal Depth, a Selection That Commits, the Strongest Objection Answered, Adoption Cost Stated, and Conditions That Would Reverse the Choice
Student Name
Capella University
PM FPX 5018: Project Management Foundations
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Project
Great Plains Mutual wants to replace the online form policyholders use to report auto and property claims. The current form is a long single page; about 40% of people who start it abandon it, and many call instead, adding load to the claims call center. The new intake should guide policyholders step by step, let them upload photos, and send the claim directly into the claims system. The budget is about 600,000 dollars, and the executive sponsor, who runs the claims function, wants a first version within six months so policyholders see a change before the spring storm season.
Criteria Drawn From the Organization
The criteria come from Great Plains' own situation, not a general list. First, uncertainty about what policyholders need: high, since the abandonment problem is known but its causes are not. Second, regulatory requirements: claims must be acknowledged within the time limits state insurance rules set, and records of what was reported must be kept; these requirements are known and stable. Third, integration with the legacy claims system: technically risky, but the integration points are known. Fourth, availability of business experts: two senior claims adjusters can each give about half their time. Fifth, the organization's maturity: Great Plains has little formal project management and no agile experience, as the division's maturity assessment found. Sixth, the sponsor's expectation of visible progress within six months.
Both Approaches at Equal Depth
Predictive: requirements would be gathered over about two months, designs approved, the intake built and integrated, tested, and launched at month six. Strengths: fits the known regulatory requirements; gives a single plan executives can follow; suits an organization without agile experience. Weaknesses: the design would be fixed before any policyholder tried it, so if the causes of abandonment are misunderstood, the new form could fail the same way; progress would be invisible until testing. Agile, using Scrum: a product owner from claims, a Scrum Master, and a cross-functional team of six would work in two-week sprints, releasing a working intake for auto glass claims, the simplest type, by month three, then expanding to other claim types. Strengths: real policyholders would use early versions, showing whether the step-by-step design reduces abandonment; the sponsor would see working software every two weeks; regulatory checks could be built into the definition of done. Weaknesses: requires a product owner with authority and time; the organization has no experience with the method; the legacy integration may not suit small increments. Serrador and Pinto (2015), using a large sample of projects across industries, found that the extent of agile use was positively associated with perceived project success, both in efficiency and in stakeholder satisfaction, though the method's fit to the project still matters.
A Selection That Commits
The project will use Scrum. The deciding criterion is uncertainty about policyholders' needs: the project's purpose is to reduce abandonment, and the only reliable way to learn whether a new design does that is to put it in front of policyholders early. A predictive plan would commit to a design based on guesses and reveal whether it works only at launch. The project exists to find out why people abandon the form. Only early use can answer that.
The Strongest Objection Answered
The strongest objection comes from the compliance officer: an agile project will produce less documentation, and regulators may ask how the intake ensures timely acknowledgment and complete records. The answer is built into the approach. Every regulatory requirement becomes an acceptance criterion on the relevant backlog items, and the definition of done includes a compliance review by the compliance officer's designate before any release. A traceability record, maintained by the product owner, links each requirement to the items and tests that satisfy it. This produces documentation as the work proceeds rather than in advance.
Adoption Cost Stated Honestly
Adopting Scrum has costs. Training: two days for the team, product owner, and sponsor, about 12,000 dollars. An experienced agile coach for three months, about 45,000 dollars. The product owner's time: one senior claims adjuster at about 60% of her time for six months, meaning her claims caseload must be reassigned. Early sprints will be slower as the team learns. The legacy integration may need a separate, more planned workstream alongside the sprints. Boehm and Turner (2004) note that organizations adopting agile methods without experience often underestimate the cultural change required.
How the Legacy Integration Will Be Handled
The integration with the legacy claims system will run as a planned technical track within the Scrum project. Two developers who know the claims system will build the integration points in the order the backlog needs them, with the first, creating a claim record for auto glass claims, targeted for sprint 3. This keeps the riskiest technical work visible in every sprint review rather than hidden until the end.
Governance With the Executive Committee
Because Great Plains' executive committee is used to reviewing projects against a plan, the product owner and sponsor will present a release plan at the start, showing which claim types are expected in which months, and update it each month with actual progress and the abandonment rate on released versions. This gives the committee the forecast it needs while keeping the flexibility to change the order of work.
Conditions That Would Reverse the Choice
The choice would be reversed if: the claims department cannot release a product owner with decision authority for at least half her time; the first two sprints show that the legacy integration cannot deliver even a thin working slice, meaning nothing usable could be released early; or regulators require approval of the full design before any release. If any of these occurs, the project would move to a predictive plan for the remaining work, keeping what was learned about policyholders from the early releases and the working auto glass intake already in use.
Conclusion
Criteria drawn from Great Plains' situation point to high uncertainty about user needs as the deciding factor. Both approaches were examined equally, and Scrum is chosen because early releases can show whether the new intake reduces abandonment. The compliance objection is answered through acceptance criteria, a compliance step in the definition of done, and traceability. Adoption costs about 57,000 dollars plus the product owner's time, and three named conditions would reverse the choice.
References
Boehm, B., & Turner, R. (2004). Balancing agility and discipline: A guide for the perplexed. Addison-Wesley.
Serrador, P., & Pinto, J. K. (2015). Does Agile work? A quantitative analysis of agile project success. International Journal of Project Management, 33(5), 1040-1051. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2015.01.006
What the PM FPX 5018 Assessment 2 instructions ask for
Assessment 2 in PM FPX 5018 has you compare project management approaches for a specific project and recommend one. You restate the organizational context, set criteria drawn from the organization and the project, such as regulatory constraints, requirement stability and stakeholder availability, analyze each approach against the criteria at equal depth, choose one, answer the strongest objection, estimate the cost of adoption and name what would make you choose differently. A hybrid is acceptable if justified, as long as the paper says which practices come from each approach. Peer-reviewed research comparing methodologies and the organizational analysis from Assessment 1 support the recommendation.
How the PM-FPX5018 Assessment 2 example is put together
The example is organized by criteria, not by approach, and that choice is deliberate. It opens by restating the organizational case in a compact paragraph, because the comparison only means something against a specific setting. A criteria section then states what the approaches are being judged on and justifies each criterion from the organization's own conditions, which is the step most papers skip. The body takes each criterion in turn and holds both approaches inside the same section, keeping their order consistent throughout, with citations on both sides. A selection section commits to one approach and states what the organization gives up by choosing it. A counterargument section answers the strongest objection instead of avoiding it. The closing section names the conditions that would make the rejected approach correct, which reads as judgment rather than hedging.
Where the marks sit in the PM FPX 5018 Assessment 2 scoring guide
The scoring guide rewards a comparison organized by criteria rather than by approach. Criteria reach Distinguished when drawn from this organization, not from a textbook list. The analysis scores higher when both approaches get equal depth, with the same criteria applied to each. The selection earns credit when it commits to one approach. The strongest objection is judged on whether it is stated fairly and answered. Adoption cost should include training, tools and disruption, since a method the staff cannot yet use delivers nothing. Reversal conditions show the choice is reasoned, such as regulators requiring full specifications before build. Distinguished comparisons would survive a skeptical executive committee.
PM FPX 5018 Assessment 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
Methodology comparisons often favor agile from the start and give the predictive approach a straw-man treatment. Another weakness is using generic criteria that could apply to any organization. The comparison runs approach by approach, so the reader has to do the matching across pages. The recommendation hedges with "a hybrid of both" without saying which parts come from where. Adoption costs are ignored. The strongest objection is avoided, which leaves the recommendation exposed at the first executive meeting. Building a table of criteria with a short verdict for each approach, followed by a clear choice and one paragraph answering the best counterargument, makes the recommendation convincing.
Get a PM FPX 5018 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 2 instructions and the scoring guide from your PM FPX 5018 courseroom, plus the organization and the two approaches your section expects. We write a custom example to those criteria, judged on organizational fit and defended against the strongest objection, and return it in 24 to 48 hours. First one free. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More PM FPX 5018 papers and MS in Project Management samples
- PM FPX 5018 Assessment 1: Organizational Project Analysis
- PM FPX 5018 Assessment 3: Professional Practice Paper
PM FPX 5018 Assessment 2 questions, answered
Which two approaches should I compare?
The two that are genuinely plausible for your organization, unless the instructions name them. A predictive approach against an adaptive one is the common pairing because the tradeoff is real, though a hybrid against either can work when the organization already runs both. Comparing an approach nobody would consider wastes half the paper and weakens the selection you reach.
Can I recommend a hybrid?
Yes, if you specify it. A hybrid is a real answer when the paper says which parts of the work run predictively, which run adaptively, where the boundary sits and how the two halves report into one governance structure. A hybrid used to avoid choosing, with no boundary described, reads as evasion and the criterion treats it that way.
Does the organization have to be the same one from Assessment 1?
In many sections it is meant to be, since the course builds an argument about a single case. Check your instructions. Carrying the same organization forward is usually the stronger move, because the structural conditions you already established become the criteria this comparison judges on, and the paper gains depth instead of restarting from a new description.
Where can I find a free PM FPX 5018 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page presents the full methodology comparison for the claims intake project, with criteria drawn from the organization, both approaches at equal depth, a committed selection and the strongest objection answered.
Can I recommend a hybrid approach in PM FPX 5018 Assessment 2?
Yes, if you say exactly which elements come from each approach and why. A hybrid with no specifics reads as avoiding the decision.