| Course | PSY FPX 5110 Ethics and Individual Differences in Psychology |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 1 |
| Paper type | Ethics case analysis |
| Length | About 1,260 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | MS in Psychology |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 1
The CEO Wants the Individual Scores: An Ethics Case Analysis of Confidential 360-Degree Feedback, With the Hard Facts Kept In, Obligations Mapped to Each Party, Principles and Standards Used Differently, and Two Courses Worked Through
Student Name
Capella University
PSY FPX 5110: Ethics and Individual Differences in Psychology
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Case, With the Hard Facts Kept In
Lauren Price, a composite consultant with a master's degree in industrial-organizational psychology, runs a leadership development program for a 400-employee regional logistics company. As part of the program, 22 managers received 360-degree feedback, in which supervisors, peers, and direct reports rated them anonymously. Before the survey, Lauren's written introduction, approved by the human resources director, told managers that their individual reports would be seen only by themselves and by Lauren in a coaching session, and that the company would receive only group-level results. Three weeks after the reports were delivered, the chief executive, Mark Hollis, asked Lauren for the individual reports of four managers. He explained that the company is closing one of its two warehouses, that one of the four will lose a position, and that he wants "all the information we have." He reminded Lauren that the company is paying for the program and that its contract says work products belong to the company. Several facts make this harder than it first appears. The contract does say that work products belong to the company, and it does not mention the confidentiality promise. The human resources director approved the promise but did not have authority to amend the contract. One of the four managers has very poor ratings from direct reports that describe behavior the chief executive may have a legitimate interest in knowing about. And Lauren's firm depends on this client for about a fifth of its revenue.
Obligations Mapped to Named Parties
Lauren has obligations to several parties, and they differ. To the 22 managers, and especially to the four named, Lauren owes the confidentiality she promised. They completed the process and received feedback under that promise, and their raters gave candid comments on the same understanding. To the raters, the peers and direct reports who rated the managers, Lauren owes protection of the anonymity that made candid ratings possible. Individual reports contain verbatim comments that may identify raters. In a company of this size, where most managers have five to eight direct reports, a comment about a specific incident can point to one person. To the company as a client, Lauren owes competent work, honesty about what she can and cannot provide, and a way to meet its legitimate needs if one exists. To the chief executive, as the client's representative, Lauren owes a clear explanation, not an evasion. To her profession, Lauren owes conduct that preserves trust in assessment: a manager who learns that confidential feedback was used in a layoff decision will not trust the next one.
Principles and Standards Used Differently
The Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct contains two kinds of material, and they do different work in this analysis (American Psychological Association [APA], 2017). The general principles, such as fidelity and responsibility and respect for people's rights and dignity, are aspirational; they describe what psychologists should aim for and help interpret the situation. The standards are enforceable rules and determine what Lauren must and must not do. The principles frame the stakes. Fidelity and responsibility calls for keeping promises and establishing relationships of trust; respect for rights and dignity calls for protecting privacy and confidentiality. The standards decide the question. Standard 3.07 requires a psychologist who works for one party at another's request to settle, before the work starts, who the client is, what the information will be used for, and where confidentiality ends (APA, 2017). Lauren did this, and the stated limit was that individual reports would not go to the company. Psychologists must protect confidential information obtained through their work (APA, 2017, Standard 4.01), and they may disclose it without consent only in narrow circumstances, none of which include an employer's staffing decision (APA, 2017, Standard 4.05). When organizational demands conflict with the code, psychologists clarify the conflict, make known their commitment to the code, and seek a resolution consistent with it (APA, 2017, Standard 1.03).
Two Courses Worked Through to Consequences
Course A: release the four reports. The chief executive gets what he asked for, the client relationship is protected in the short term, and Lauren avoids a dispute over the contract. The consequences are serious. Lauren breaks a written promise, in violation of the standards on confidentiality. The four managers learn, or eventually suspect, that feedback was used against them. Raters whose comments may be recognizable are exposed. The company's future development programs lose credibility, and so does Lauren's practice with every other client who hears of it. Lauren would also be exposed to a complaint to her professional association or, if she is a member, to its ethics committee, and the promise she broke is in writing. Course B: decline to release the reports and offer alternatives. Lauren explains to the chief executive, in writing, what managers were told and why she cannot release individual results. She offers what she can provide: the group-level results already delivered; an explanation of why 360-degree ratings gathered for development are poorly suited to layoff decisions, since raters were not asked to evaluate for that purpose; and help designing a fair selection process for the remaining position, such as a structured assessment of the competencies the new role requires. She also offers to ask each of the four managers whether they would voluntarily share their reports, making clear that declining will have no consequence. The consequences: the chief executive may be angry, may argue the contract, and may end the engagement; Lauren's firm may lose a fifth of its revenue. The managers' and raters' trust is preserved, and the company is steered toward a better basis for its decision. Feedback gathered to help a manager grow is poor evidence for deciding whether that manager keeps a job.
The Decision and What It Costs, Admitted
Course B is the right choice, because the standards on confidentiality and third-party services are clear, the promise was explicit, and the alternatives offered meet the company's legitimate need for a fair decision. The contract issue should be addressed directly: Lauren should say that the confidentiality commitment was part of the service the company approved through its human resources director, and that she will revise her contracts to state such limits in the future. The decision has real costs, and they should not be minimized. Lauren may lose her largest client. The chief executive may make the staffing decision with less information than he wanted, including information about the manager whose direct reports described troubling behavior. That behavior, if serious, is a matter the company can address through its own channels, such as asking the direct reports to raise it through human resources, but Lauren cannot be the conduit. Choosing Course B means accepting that an ethical decision may leave a legitimate organizational concern less well served in the short term.
Conclusion
The case sets a clear promise of confidentiality against a paying client's demand. Mapping obligations shows that the managers and raters have the strongest claims, the standards settle the question in their favor, and working both courses through shows that declining with alternatives protects trust at a real cost to the consultant and, in the short term, to the client's information.
References
American Psychological Association. (2017). Ethical principles of psychologists and code of conduct (2002, amended effective June 1, 2010, and January 1, 2017). https://www.apa.org/ethics/code
PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 1 instructions, in plain terms
The first assessment in PSY FPX 5110 centers on an ethical dilemma from psychological practice and how you reason through it. You describe the facts without leaving out the difficult ones, identify everyone with a stake and what is owed to each, apply the APA Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct, distinguishing aspirational principles from enforceable standards, consider more than one course of action and its consequences, recommend a course and explain how the dilemma could have been prevented. A structured decision model, such as Knapp and VandeCreek's, supports the analysis.
How the PSY-FPX5110 Assessment 1 example is put together
The paper is laid out as a decision trail, and each stage is visible. It opens with the facts of the case restated neutrally, including the facts that make the situation hard, since a summary that sands off the difficulty produces an easy answer nobody asked for. The second stage maps obligations to parties, one short paragraph per stakeholder, which is what turns a story into an ethical problem with structure. The third stage brings the code in, principles first for orientation and then the specific standards that govern, each quoted sparingly and applied to this case rather than restated. The fourth stage sets out at least two defensible courses of action and works each one to its consequences before choosing. The fifth commits, gives its reasons, and then names what the chosen course sacrifices, plus the changed fact that would have reversed the judgment.
Reading the PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 1 scoring guide
This analysis is graded on the handling of facts, the mapping of obligations, the use of the ethics code, the comparison of courses of action, the recommendation and prevention. Facts reach Distinguished when the difficult ones are kept in, such as the psychologist having promised confidentiality in a kickoff meeting without checking the contract. Obligations score higher when mapped to each party, including the employees who gave feedback, the executives rated and the organization paying the fee. The code earns credit when principles, such as respect for people's rights, guide reasoning while specific standards, like those on confidentiality and multiple relationships, set the limits. Courses of action are judged on whether at least two are worked through with consequences. The recommendation should follow from the analysis. Prevention should address contracting. A Proficient analysis cites the code; a Distinguished one uses it to reason.
PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 1 help: mistakes that cost marks
Ethics case analyses often jump to the obvious answer and cite a standard to support it, skipping the reasoning the assessment is looking for. Another weakness is leaving out facts that make the case hard, so the dilemma looks simpler than it is. Obligations are described only toward the client who pays, ignoring the people who gave feedback. Principles and standards are quoted interchangeably, although principles guide and standards require. Only one course of action is considered. Prevention is missing, even though most such conflicts start with unclear agreements. Mapping each party and what is owed to them in a small table before applying the code keeps the analysis thorough and prepares the individual differences paper in Assessment 2.
Get a PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 1 example written to your instructions
Post over the Assessment 1 instructions and scoring guide from your PSY FPX 5110 courseroom, along with the case your section assigns if it supplies one. The example is argued against that case and those criteria, and it usually reaches you inside 24-48h. First custom sample, no charge. The reasoning in your own submission has to be yours. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More PSY FPX 5110 papers and MS in Psychology samples
- PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 2: Individual Differences Paper
- PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 3: Ethical Assessment Critique
- PSY FPX 5120 Assessment 1: Literature Synthesis
- PSY FPX 5002 Assessment 1: Theoretical Perspectives Synthesis
- PSY FPX 5140 Assessment 1: Program Logic Model
- PSY FPX 6840 Assessment 1: Issue Survey
PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 1 questions, answered
Does the analysis have to reach a single resolution?
In nearly all sections, yes. Ethics assessments are built to test whether you can act under uncertainty, and a paper that lays out considerations without choosing has performed the easier half of the task. Choose, argue the choice from the code, and then state the conditions under which you would have gone the other way; conditional commitment reads as professional judgment, while permanent balance reads as evasion.
How much of the ethics code should I quote?
Very little, and always in service of an application. A standard reproduced at length occupies space the analysis needs and demonstrates only that you can find the document. Name the standard, give the clause that bears on your case in a few words, then spend the paragraph showing what it requires here and where it collides with something else the code also demands.
Is this the same paper as the assessment critique later in the course?
They share the code and nothing else. This one takes a dilemma between obligations and argues a way through it; the later piece asks what responsible use of a psychological measure requires in a described setting, which pulls in reliability, validity, norms and the reporting of scores. Carrying paragraphs from one into the other leaves both criteria half met.
Where can I find a free PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 1 sample paper?
The 360-degree feedback ethics case is analyzed here in full, with the hard facts kept in, obligations mapped to each party, principles and standards used differently and two courses of action worked through.
Does the analysis have to reach a single resolution in PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 1?
It should recommend one course and explain why, while acknowledging the costs and the reasonable alternatives.