| Course | PSY FPX 5110 Ethics and Individual Differences in Psychology |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Ethical assessment critique |
| Length | About 1,100 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | MS in Psychology |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 3
A Clinical Inventory in a Promotion Decision: An Ethical Assessment Critique That Fixes the Use First, Evaluates Validity for This Purpose, Checks Norms Against the People Tested, Applies the Code, and Reaches a Conditional Verdict
Student Name
Capella University
PSY FPX 5110: Ethics and Individual Differences in Psychology
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Use Fixed Before the Judgment
A test cannot be judged valid or invalid in general; it can only be judged for a particular use. Hartwell Home Goods, a composite chain of 38 home furnishings stores, has for three years required hourly employees who apply for promotion to assistant store manager to complete a well-known clinical personality inventory, one designed to assess psychopathology in clinical settings. A regional human resources manager scores the results using software supplied with the test and removes candidates whose profiles show elevations on scales associated with depression, paranoia, or antisocial tendencies. Candidates who pass the screen proceed to interviews. About 180 employees apply each year, and about a quarter are removed at this step. No record is kept of which scales led to each removal, and candidates are told only that they did not advance. The use to be evaluated, therefore, is this: screening internal candidates out of consideration for a retail management role on the basis of scores on a clinical inventory, interpreted by someone without training in psychological assessment.
Validity Evaluated for This Purpose
The Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing state that validity refers to the degree to which evidence and theory support the interpretations of test scores for proposed uses, and that evidence must be gathered for each intended use (American Educational Research Association [AERA] et al., 2014). The relevant question is not whether the inventory is a sound clinical instrument, which it may be, but whether its scale elevations predict performance as an assistant store manager. The retailer has no such evidence. It has not conducted a job analysis linking the inventory's scales to the requirements of the role, it has not compared the performance of promoted managers with their scores, and the test publisher's materials describe clinical uses, not selection for retail management. The traits the role plausibly requires, such as dependability, customer orientation, and skill in scheduling and supervising staff, are not what clinical scales were built to measure. A high score on a scale associated with depression, for example, says nothing about whether a candidate can build a weekly schedule for 30 employees or handle a customer complaint, and a low score is not evidence that the candidate can. On the evidence available, the use lacks validity support.
Norms Checked Against the People Tested
Scores on a clinical inventory are interpreted by comparing them with a normative sample. The inventory's general norms are based on adults from the population at large, and its clinical interpretations draw on research with people in treatment settings. Neither group matches the people being tested here: employees applying for promotion, who are motivated to present themselves well and whose response style differs from that of people seeking help. Profiles from job applicants often show defensive patterns that the clinical norms were not designed to interpret. Using those norms to label a promotion candidate as elevated on a clinical scale compares the candidate with the wrong reference group. The candidates are compared with the population the test was built for, and that population is not them.
Code Obligations Run Through the Situation
Several obligations of the Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct apply, since the retailer relies on an instrument from the psychological profession and would need psychologists to defend its use (American Psychological Association [APA], 2017). Assessments are to be used in ways and for purposes that are appropriate in light of research on the usefulness and proper application of the techniques (APA, 2017, Standard 9.02). Psychologists do not promote the use of psychological assessment techniques by unqualified persons (APA, 2017, Standard 9.07), and the human resources manager scoring the inventory has no training in its interpretation. Test results are to be interpreted with attention to factors that might affect their accuracy, such as the test-taker's situation (APA, 2017, Standard 9.06). The law adds a separate concern. Screening employees for mental disorders in connection with promotion is not only a question of test quality but of disability law. A federal appeals court held (Karraker v. Rent-A-Center, Inc., 2005) that an employer's use of a clinical personality inventory as part of its management promotion testing was a medical examination under the Americans with Disabilities Act, because the test could reveal mental disorders, and that the employer's use of it violated the statute. The retailer's practice closely resembles the one the court considered.
A Conditional Verdict With Its Conditions
The verdict is that the current use is not defensible and should stop. It lacks validity evidence for the purpose, relies on norms that do not fit the people tested, places interpretation in untrained hands, and closely resembles a practice a federal court found unlawful. The verdict on the retailer's underlying aim, identifying candidates likely to succeed as assistant managers, is conditional. A selection process for the role could be defensible if four conditions were met. First, a job analysis identifies the knowledge, skills, and characteristics the role requires. Second, instruments designed for employee selection, not clinical diagnosis, are chosen to measure those characteristics, such as a structured interview and a work sample of scheduling and supervising tasks. Third, the instruments' validity for this role is supported by evidence, ideally the retailer's own data on promoted managers' performance. Fourth, scoring and interpretation are done by qualified people or under their supervision, with the process reviewed by employment counsel.
What the Retailer Owes Those Already Screened
About 135 employees have been screened out over three years. The critique cannot say whether any would have succeeded, but the retailer should consider inviting those still employed to reapply under the new process, and it should consult counsel on its obligations regarding the records it holds, which contain information of a medical character. It should also tell current and future candidates, in writing, that the inventory is no longer used and how the new process works, since employees who were screened out may otherwise conclude that the new process repeats the old one.
Conclusion
Evaluated for its actual use, the retailer's promotion screen fails on validity, norms, qualifications, and legal grounds. Its goal is legitimate and could be met with a process built on job analysis, selection instruments validated for the role, and qualified interpretation.
References
American Educational Research Association, American Psychological Association, & National Council on Measurement in Education. (2014). Standards for educational and psychological testing. American Educational Research Association.
American Psychological Association. (2017). Ethical principles of psychologists and code of conduct (2002, amended effective June 1, 2010, and January 1, 2017). https://www.apa.org/ethics/code
Karraker v. Rent-A-Center, Inc., 411 F.3d 831 (7th Cir. 2005).
What the PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 3 instructions ask for
The final assessment in PSY FPX 5110 asks you to critique the ethical use of a psychological assessment. You identify the instrument and exactly how it will be used, evaluate whether validity evidence supports that particular use, check whether the norm group matches the people being tested, apply the APA Ethics Code standards on assessment and consider legal issues, such as the Americans with Disabilities Act's restrictions on medical examinations in employment. You then reach a reasoned verdict, which may be conditional or negative. Professional testing standards from AERA, APA and NCME support the critique.
How this PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 3 example is built
The paper is built as a single question worked from two directions, and the setting is fixed before either direction opens. An opening section describes the assessment context concretely, the population, the purpose, the decision, the people who will read the results, because the same instrument is defensible in one use and indefensible in another. A technical section then evaluates the measure against that use: what the validity evidence covers, whether the norms include this population, how much error surrounds an individual score, and what the publisher intends the instrument for. An ethical section runs the same situation through the code, competence, consent, interpretation, disclosure. A synthesis section brings the two verdicts together, since a technically adequate measure used without consent fails as surely as a well-consented use of the wrong instrument. The closing states conditions for defensible use, or recommends against use and says why.
Reading the PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 3 scoring guide
Marks go to the statement of intended use, the validity evaluation, the check on norms, the application of the code and law, and the verdict. The use reaches Distinguished when fixed precisely before any evaluation, since validity always depends on purpose. Validity scores higher when evaluated for this use, asking whether a clinical inventory predicts managerial performance, not just whether it is valid in general. Norms earn credit when compared with the people to be tested, such as clinical and community samples versus employed managers. The code and law are judged on specificity, citing standards on the bases for assessment and the ADA's limits on medical examinations. The verdict should be reasoned and may be conditional. The people tested should remain central. Distinguished critiques protect those being assessed.
PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 3 help from the desk
Assessment critiques often evaluate a test in general, praising its reliability, without asking whether it suits the specific use. Another weakness is ignoring norm groups, so scores are interpreted against people very different from those tested. The ethics code is quoted without being applied to the case. Legal issues, such as the ADA's treatment of clinical instruments as medical examinations, are missed. The verdict is unconditional. Personal opinion about personality testing replaces validity evidence. The employees' perspective is absent. Stating the use in one sentence and then asking whether each type of evidence supports that use keeps the critique precise and ends the course with an ethical judgment grounded in psychometrics.
Get a PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
Attach the Assessment 3 instructions and scoring guide from your PSY FPX 5110 courseroom, plus the measure and setting your section works with. The critique is drafted to those criteria, technical and ethical halves joined, and returns in 24-48h with no fee on a first custom sample. It is written to study from, not to submit. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More PSY FPX 5110 papers and MS in Psychology samples
- PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 1: Ethics Case Analysis
- PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 2: Individual Differences Paper
- PSY FPX 5120 Assessment 3: Practitioner Recommendation Brief
- PSY FPX 5002 Assessment 3: Specialization Plan
- PSY FPX 5140 Assessment 3: Stakeholder Evaluation Report
- PSY FPX 6840 Assessment 3: Practice Implications Argument
PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 3 questions, answered
What if my section does not name a specific instrument?
Choose one with a published technical manual and a real research base, then build the setting yourself: who is being assessed, for what decision, by whom. The analysis needs a concrete use to bite on, and a well-documented measure gives you validity and norming evidence to argue from. Obscure or proprietary instruments with no published psychometrics leave the technical half with nothing.
Can I critique a measure used at my workplace?
Often yes, with the workplace disguised and no individual's results discussed. Describe the practice at the level of policy: which instrument, for which decisions, with what training behind its use. Real employees, clients or students must not be identifiable, and any results you have seen stay out of the paper entirely, since your access to them came with obligations the assessment does not lift.
Is a recommendation against using the measure an acceptable answer?
It is, when the argument earns it. Some instruments are used routinely for decisions their validity evidence does not support, and a paper that documents the mismatch and says so is doing precisely what the course teaches. What weakens such a verdict is refusal without analysis, so show the evidence, name the standards, and state what a defensible alternative would look like.
Where can I find a free PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 3 sample paper?
The complete critique of a clinical inventory in a promotion decision is here, fixing the use first, evaluating validity for this purpose, checking norms against the people tested and applying the code.
Is recommending against the measure acceptable in PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 3?
Yes, if the evidence supports that verdict. A reasoned recommendation not to use a test for a given purpose is a valid conclusion.