| Course | PSY FPX 5140 Program Evaluation |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Stakeholder evaluation report |
| Length | About 1,100 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | MS in Psychology |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for PSY FPX 5140 Assessment 3
Summer Works After Two Summers: A Stakeholder Evaluation Report With an Executive Summary That Stands Alone, Findings Arranged by Question, Unwelcome Results Given Equal Prominence, and Owned, Time-Bound Recommendations
Student Name
Capella University
PSY FPX 5140: Program Evaluation
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Executive Summary
Summer Works placed 600 young people aged 14 to 18 in paid summer jobs with mentoring over two summers. Because more youth applied than there were places, participants were chosen by lottery, which allowed a fair comparison between the 600 who were offered a place and the 1,200 applicants who were not. Youth offered a place were more likely to work for pay the following summer: 41% compared with 33%, a difference unlikely to be due to chance. Youth offered a place had fewer violent-crime arrests over the following 16 months, 3.1 compared with 4.4 per 100 youth, but this difference could be due to chance, and two summers are not yet enough to be confident about it. Youth offered a place did not have better school attendance the following fall; attendance was essentially the same in both groups. The program was delivered largely as designed, though mentor meetings fell short of the weekly target at about a third of job sites. The agency recommends continuing the program at its current size for one more summer while the evidence on violence accumulates, and strengthening mentoring at the weakest sites. Expansion to 500 places should be decided next year with three summers of data. The full findings, with the numbers behind each, follow in the order of the questions the council asked when the evaluation began.
Question 1: Did Youth Work More the Following Summer?
Yes. According to state wage records, 41% of youth offered a place worked for pay the following summer, compared with 33% of those not offered a place, a difference of 8 percentage points, with a 95% confidence interval of about 3 to 13 points. This finding answers the question the agency considers central to the program's purpose: whether a first job leads to another. It is also the only one of the three outcome results that is both clearly positive and clearly larger than chance, which makes it the program's strongest claim to date.
Question 2: Did Violent-Crime Arrests Fall?
Possibly, but the evidence is not yet conclusive. Over 16 months after the program, youth offered a place had 3.1 violent-crime arrests per 100, compared with 4.4 per 100 for youth not offered a place. The difference is in the direction found in the Chicago study that informed the program's design (Heller, 2014), and its size is roughly similar, but it is not statistically significant: the 95% confidence interval for the difference runs from about 0.5 more to 3.1 fewer arrests per 100 youth. The evaluation design anticipated that two summers might not be enough to detect an effect of this size, and a third summer is expected to provide a clearer answer. Until then, the council should treat the violence result as encouraging but unconfirmed; describing it as a proven reduction would overstate what two summers show, and describing it as no effect would understate it.
Question 3: Did School Attendance Improve?
No. Fall attendance was 91.2% for youth offered a place and 91.0% for youth not offered a place, a difference too small to matter even if it were real. This is an important result, because improved school engagement was one of the benefits most often cited for the program when it was funded. The program, as currently designed, does not appear to affect it. The evaluation team discussed whether to present this finding more gently and decided against it: the council's decision next year will be better if it rests on what the program does rather than on what it was hoped to do. The benefit cited most often when the program was funded is the one the evaluation could not find.
Question 4: Was the Program Delivered as Designed?
Mostly. Of youth offered a place, 88% started and 79% completed six weeks. Mentor logs showed that weekly meetings occurred for 71% of participant-weeks overall, but at 11 of 34 site groups the rate was below 50%. Site visits found real work under supervision at 26 of 30 sites visited; at four, youth had long periods without assigned tasks. Completion was lower at those four sites, 64% compared with 81% elsewhere, although the small number of sites means this comparison is suggestive only.
Recommendations, Owned and Time-Bound
Continue the program at 300 places next summer, and decide on expansion in March of next year with three summers of data. Owner: city council, on the recommendation of the Department of Youth Services. Raise mentoring at the weakest sites to the weekly target by reducing each mentor's caseload at those sites from 12 to 9 youth before next June. Owner: agency program director. Replace the four job sites where youth lacked assigned work before placements are made in May. Owner: agency employer relations manager. Stop citing improved school attendance as an expected benefit in program materials beginning with this year's recruitment. If the council wants a school effect, the agency should propose, by January, a school-linked component, such as coordination with school counselors, and evaluate it separately. Owner: agency executive director. Continue the data-sharing agreements for arrests, attendance, and wages through the third summer. Owner: city attorney's office and the evaluator.
Technical Appendix
The comparison uses all applicants, analyzed according to lottery result regardless of whether winners attended. Violent-crime arrests were counted from police and juvenile court records for the 16 months beginning at the end of each program summer. Differences in proportions were tested with two-sample tests; confidence intervals are 95%. The comparison of violent-crime arrests had a p value of about .16. Baseline characteristics of winners and non-winners, including age, sex, prior arrests, and prior school attendance, were similar, as expected from a lottery. Property-crime arrests were also examined and did not differ meaningfully between groups, 1.9 and 1.6 per 100. The employment comparison is limited to applicants aged 16 and older at the following summer, because state wage records do not cover younger workers.
Conclusion
Two summers of lottery-based evaluation show that Summer Works increases later employment, may reduce violent-crime arrests though the evidence is not yet conclusive, and does not improve school attendance. The report gives each of these results equal space and recommends continuing at current size for one more summer, fixing weak mentoring and job sites, and dropping school attendance as a promised benefit.
References
Heller, S. B. (2014). Summer jobs reduce violence among disadvantaged youth. Science, 346(6214), 1219-1223. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1257809
PSY FPX 5140 Assessment 3 instructions, in plain terms
The final assessment in PSY FPX 5140 asks you to write an evaluation report for the program's stakeholders. You summarize the whole evaluation in an executive summary a decision maker could read alone, present findings organized by the evaluation questions, report negative and null results as clearly as positive ones, explain the limitations, and make recommendations with responsible parties and timelines. The report should be written for its audience while keeping appropriate APA conventions for citations. Guidance on evaluation reporting, such as the Joint Committee's Program Evaluation Standards, supports the report.
How this PSY FPX 5140 Assessment 3 example is built
The report is sequenced by what its audience needs first, which reverses the order of a research paper. An executive summary comes before anything else and can be read alone. A short context section reminds readers what the program is and why the evaluation happened, in a paragraph rather than a chapter. Findings occupy the center, one section per evaluation question, and inside each the answer is stated before the evidence supporting it, since a reader hunting for conclusions should not have to assemble them. Recommendations follow, numbered, each naming a finding, an action, an owner and a rough timeframe. A limitations section explains in ordinary language what the evaluation could not determine, which protects the program from over-reading its own results. Methods and instruments go last, full enough for a technical reader, out of the way of everyone else.
Where the marks sit in the PSY FPX 5140 Assessment 3 scoring guide
Marks go to the executive summary, the organization by question, the treatment of unwelcome results, the limitations and the recommendations. The executive summary reaches Distinguished when it stands alone, giving the main findings and recommendations in a page. Organization scores higher when each evaluation question from Assessment 2 has its own section with its answer. Unwelcome results earn credit when given the same prominence as positive ones, rather than placed in a footnote. Limitations are judged on whether they are stated in terms stakeholders understand, such as which outcomes could not be measured. Recommendations should each have an owner and a date. The report should suit council members, not researchers. Distinguished reports are trusted because they are balanced.
Common PSY FPX 5140 Assessment 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Evaluation reports often bury null or negative findings to protect the program, which undermines the credibility of everything else in the report. Another weakness is an executive summary that only introduces the report instead of summarizing its findings. Findings follow the order data were collected in, not the questions stakeholders asked. Limitations are written in technical language no council member can follow. Recommendations have no owner or timeline, so nothing happens. The report is written for academics rather than decision makers. Tables of numbers appear without interpretation. Drafting the executive summary last, as a one-page answer to each evaluation question, then building the body to support it, keeps the report useful and ends the course with evidence decision makers can act on.
Get a PSY FPX 5140 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
Drop us the Assessment 3 instructions and scoring guide from your PSY FPX 5140 courseroom, along with the program, the audience and any findings your section supplies to report. The example is written to those criteria in 24-48h, first one free, with the summary and recommendations built the way a program board would need them. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More PSY FPX 5140 papers and MS in Psychology samples
- PSY FPX 5140 Assessment 1: Program Logic Model
- PSY FPX 5140 Assessment 2: Program Evaluation Design
- PSY FPX 5201 Assessment 3: Final Project Presentation
- PSY FPX 5120 Assessment 3: Practitioner Recommendation Brief
- PSY FPX 6010 Assessment 3: Professional Translation Piece
- PSY FPX 5110 Assessment 3: Ethical Assessment Critique
PSY FPX 5140 Assessment 3 questions, answered
What if my section gives me no data to report?
Many versions supply a data set or a scenario of results; where yours does not, construct plausible findings from your design and label them clearly as illustrative. The graded skill is the reporting, how answers are stated, how confidence is expressed, how recommendations attach to findings, and that skill is demonstrable on constructed results as long as the document never pretends they were collected.
How blunt should negative findings be?
Accurate, and placed where the audience will see them. Blunt is not the same as harsh: report what was found, attach the uncertainty honestly, and separate the finding from any judgment of the people delivering the program. Reports that hide disappointing results damage the evaluator's usefulness and lose the criteria that reward independence, while reports that editorialize about failure lose the ones that reward analysis.
Does the report still need APA formatting?
The document usually keeps APA citation and reference conventions while adopting a professional layout, and your criteria settle the balance for your section. In practice that means headings and summaries built for a working reader, sources attributed in text, and a full reference list at the end. Treating a stakeholder format as permission to drop sourcing is the version that loses marks.
Where can I find a free PSY FPX 5140 Assessment 3 sample paper?
The complete Summer Works evaluation report is here, with an executive summary that stands alone, findings arranged by question, unwelcome results given equal prominence and owned, time-bound recommendations.
How blunt should negative findings be in PSY FPX 5140 Assessment 3?
Clear and factual, without softening or dramatizing. State what was found, how confident you are and what it means for the decision.