| Course | BUS FPX 4065 Income Tax Concepts and Strategies |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 3 |
| Paper type | Tax planning strategy memo |
| Length | About 1,130 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | BS in Business |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for BUS FPX 4065 Assessment 3
Should a Landscaping Business Elect S Corporation Status for 2025? Alternatives Compared With Numbers, a Year on Every Amount, Declared Assumptions About the Future, and an Action With a Deadline
Student Name
Capella University
BUS FPX 4065: Income Tax Concepts and Strategies
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
The Question
Jordan Ellis, a composite sole proprietor who runs a landscaping business, earned a Schedule C profit of 78,000 dollars in 2024 and expects about 110,000 dollars in 2025 after adding a second crew. A friend told him that forming an LLC and electing S corporation status would save thousands in self-employment tax. This memo, written in December 2024, compares staying a sole proprietor with electing S status for 2025. Jordan files jointly with his wife Megan, who expects about 62,000 dollars of wages in 2025.
A Year on Every Amount
Every amount is tied to 2025, the year the choice would affect. The Internal Revenue Service (2024) set the 2025 amounts in Revenue Procedure 2024-40, including a joint standard deduction of 30,000 dollars and a 22% bracket running from 96,950 to 206,700 dollars of taxable income. The 2025 Social Security wage base is 176,100 dollars. Self-employment tax is 15.3% of 92.35% of net earnings up to that base. Payroll taxes on an S corporation salary are 7.65% from the employee and 7.65% from the employer. The federal unemployment tax is 0.6% of the first 7,000 dollars of wages after the usual state credit. The qualified business income deduction is 20%, and under the law in force in December 2024 it is scheduled to expire after 2025. A planning number without a year cannot be checked and may already be wrong.
Alternative A: Stay a Sole Proprietor
Self-employment tax: 110,000 dollars times 92.35% is 101,585 dollars; times 15.3% is 15,543 dollars. Half, 7,771 dollars, is deductible. Income flowing to the return: 110,000 minus 7,771 equals 102,229 dollars. Qualified business income deduction: 20% of 102,229 dollars, or 20,446 dollars. Net amount taxed from the business: 102,229 minus 20,446, or 81,783 dollars.
Alternative B: Elect S Corporation Status
Jordan would form an LLC, elect S status, and pay himself a reasonable salary. Based on what local landscaping crew supervisors earn, 60,000 dollars is used here. Payroll taxes on the salary: 4,590 dollars from Jordan and 4,590 dollars from the company, 9,180 dollars total. Federal unemployment tax is 42 dollars; state unemployment tax is assumed at about 300 dollars. New costs: a payroll service at about 1,200 dollars a year and a separate S corporation return at about 1,500 dollars. Company income after salary and costs: 110,000 minus 60,000 minus 4,590 minus 342 minus 2,700 equals 42,368 dollars, passed through to Jordan. Income flowing to the return: 60,000 in wages plus 42,368, or 102,368 dollars. Qualified business income deduction: wages are not qualified business income, so the deduction is 20% of 42,368, or 8,474 dollars. Net amount taxed from the business: 102,368 minus 8,474, or 93,894 dollars.
Alternatives Compared With Numbers
Payroll and self-employment tax: 15,543 dollars under A against 9,180 dollars under B, a saving of 6,363 dollars for B. Out-of-pocket costs for B: 342 dollars of unemployment taxes and 2,700 dollars of fees, 3,042 dollars. Income tax: B leaves 12,111 more dollars taxed, mostly because the lower qualified business income deduction offsets the saving. With the couple's combined taxable income of about 114,000 dollars, well inside the 22% bracket, that costs about 2,664 dollars. Net advantage of B in 2025: 6,363 minus 3,042 minus 2,664, or about 657 dollars.
Assumptions About the Future Declared
Assumption 1: 2025 profit of 110,000 dollars. The second crew is new, and profit could fall short. Assumption 2: a 60,000 dollar salary would be accepted as reasonable. A lower salary would save more payroll tax but increase the risk of IRS challenge. Assumption 3: the qualified business income deduction exists in 2025 as scheduled. If Congress extends it, the comparison for later years stays close; if it expires after 2025 as scheduled, the income tax offset largely disappears in 2026, and B's advantage at the same profit would rise to about 3,300 dollars. Assumption 4: rates and brackets for 2025 stay as published in Revenue Procedure 2024-40.
Risks the Numbers Do Not Show
Some effects of an election do not appear in a one-year comparison. A lower salary also lowers the Social Security earnings record on which Jordan's future retirement benefit is based, so part of today's payroll tax saving is a reduction in a later benefit. An S corporation must run payroll on a fixed schedule, file quarterly payroll returns, and issue Jordan a Form W-2, and missed payroll deposits carry penalties that can quickly erase a small saving. Once made, an election cannot be revoked and then made again for five years without IRS consent, so switching in and out as profit swings is not practical. Finally, the salary must hold up if examined; the IRS can reclassify distributions as wages when the salary is too low for the work performed, adding back tax, interest, and penalties.
The Boundary Stated Plainly
At 110,000 dollars of profit in 2025, an S election gains about 657 dollars, too little to justify the added paperwork, payroll deadlines, and risk of a salary challenge. At 150,000 dollars of profit with the same salary, the same method gives a net advantage of about 5,800 dollars, which would justify the election. The advantage grows by roughly 1,300 dollars for each added 10,000 dollars of profit and passes about 4,500 dollars at 140,000 dollars, which is roughly where the election becomes worth its burdens, or sooner if the qualified business income deduction ends. This memo does not address state tax, retirement plan design, or liability protection, which an LLC could provide without an S election. At this profit level, the friend's advice is correct in theory and nearly worthless in practice.
An Action With a Deadline
Recommendation: remain a sole proprietor for 2025. Actions: pay the fourth-quarter 2024 estimated tax by January 15, 2025; set 2025 quarterly estimates using the 110,000 dollar projection, with the first due April 15, 2025; and meet in October 2025 with actual year-to-date profit and the status of the qualified business income deduction. If the numbers then favor an election for 2026, the LLC must be formed and Form 2553 filed by March 16, 2026, since March 15 falls on a Sunday.
Conclusion
Comparing both alternatives with 2025 numbers shows that an S election would save 6,363 dollars in payroll tax but give back most of it through new costs and a smaller qualified business income deduction, leaving about 657 dollars. Jordan should stay a sole proprietor for 2025 and revisit the choice in October 2025, when profit and the law for 2026 are clearer.
References
Internal Revenue Service. (2024). Revenue Procedure 2024-40. U.S. Department of the Treasury.
BUS FPX 4065 Assessment 3 instructions, in plain terms
The final assessment in BUS FPX 4065 asks you to recommend a tax planning strategy in a memo to the taxpayer. You state the objective and the planning horizon, set out the lawful alternatives and how each works, compare their tax results with figures for the stated years, identify assumptions about income, law and circumstances that the comparison depends on, discuss risks that the numbers do not capture, such as audit exposure or added compliance costs, and recommend an action with a deadline. The memo should stay clearly within lawful planning and say so. The Code, IRS guidance on S corporations and reasonable compensation, and tax texts support the recommendation.
How the BUS-FPX4065 Assessment 3 example is put together
Objective, alternatives, comparison, boundary, action. The opening states what the taxpayer is trying to achieve and over what horizon, since planning without a horizon has no basis for comparison. An alternatives block sets out each lawful course with its mechanics. A comparison block computes the consequence of each, with the year every amount falls in stated, and totals them over the horizon rather than for one year alone. An assumptions block names what the comparison depends on about future rates, income or the law itself. A boundary block states plainly where lawful arrangement ends, in terms of disclosure and substance. An action block says what has to be done, by when, and by whom. The closing names what would make the recommendation wrong.
Reading the BUS FPX 4065 Assessment 3 scoring guide
This scoring guide rewards a memo that compares real alternatives with numbers and ends with something the taxpayer can do. The objective reaches Distinguished when stated with a horizon. Alternatives score higher when each is explained with its mechanics, such as how an S corporation splits income between salary and distributions. The comparison earns credit when figures are given for each alternative with the year stated. Assumptions are judged on whether they are declared, including the salary level the IRS would treat as reasonable. Risks outside the numbers, such as payroll costs and scrutiny of low salaries, should be named. The boundary between avoidance and evasion should be stated. A deadline, such as the election due date, completes the memo.
Common BUS FPX 4065 Assessment 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Planning memos often recommend the S corporation election because it saves self-employment tax, without running the numbers for this business. Another weakness is setting an unrealistically low salary, which is the point the IRS examines most. Amounts appear without years. Assumptions about next year's profit are hidden. Costs of the new structure, such as payroll processing and a separate return, are left out, so the savings are overstated. The memo ends with a recommendation but no action or date. Presenting the two alternatives in a side-by-side table for 2025, with each assumption listed underneath, gives the owner a clear basis for deciding and shows the scorer the comparison was done rather than asserted.
Get a BUS FPX 4065 Assessment 3 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 3 instructions and the BUS FPX 4065 scoring guide from your courseroom, with the position and computation your earlier assessments produced. We write a custom example against those exact criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and comparing two lawful timings with years attached is what makes a planning memo usable. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More BUS FPX 4065 papers and BS in Business samples
- BUS FPX 4065 Assessment 1: Taxable Position With Authority
- BUS FPX 4065 Assessment 2: Computation and Return Work
- BUS FPX 4068 Assessment 3: Fraud Examination Write Up
- BUS FPX 4064 Assessment 3: Variance Investigation
- BUS FPX 4070 Assessment 3: Capital Structure Recommendation
- BUS FPX 4063 Assessment 3: Translation and Reporting Trends
BUS FPX 4065 Assessment 3 questions, answered
Where exactly is the line between avoidance and evasion?
Arranging affairs within the law to reduce a bill is lawful and expected. Hiding or dressing up the facts to reach the same result is not. The practical tests are disclosure and substance: whether the arrangement is reported accurately, and whether it has a purpose beyond the tax outcome it produces.
How far ahead should a plan look?
Far enough that the timing effects show, which usually means two or three years. A one year view makes deferral look like saving when it is only postponement. State the horizon you chose, because the comparison between alternatives depends entirely on where you stopped counting.
What if the law might change?
Name it as a risk and say what the plan would look like without the provision. Strategies resting on a rule under active review deserve a sentence acknowledging that. It is the kind of qualification that distinguishes a memo written by somebody thinking about the taxpayer from one written to the arithmetic.
Where can I find a free BUS FPX 4065 Assessment 3 sample paper?
The full memo on the S corporation election is here, with the alternatives compared in numbers, a year on every amount, declared assumptions, the risks the numbers miss and an action with a deadline.
What is reasonable compensation in BUS FPX 4065 Assessment 3?
The salary an S corporation owner who works in the business must pay themselves, set at what similar work would pay elsewhere. Too low a salary invites the IRS to reclassify distributions as wages.