| Course | MBA FPX 5012 Marketing Management |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Assessment 2 |
| Paper type | Positioning and marketing mix defense |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Capella University |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for MBA FPX 5012 Assessment 2
Positioning a Home Espresso Subscription Against the Rivals Buyers Actually Consider: A Specialty Roaster's Marketing Mix Defense
Student Name
Capella University
MBA FPX 5012: Marketing Management
Instructor Name
Month Day, Year
Introduction
A composite specialty coffee roaster, here called Northfield Roasting, sells whole-bean coffee through its two cafes and wholesale accounts. It plans to launch a subscription aimed at home espresso drinkers who own a semi-automatic machine and grinder. This paper identifies the rivals that segment actually considers, derives positioning dimensions from what the segment values, states a position that concedes something, traces each element of the marketing mix back to that position, and resolves the contradictions that appeared in the first draft of the plan.
Rivals the Segment Actually Considers
The segment does not compare Northfield with every coffee brand. Interviews with 24 home espresso drinkers from Northfield's cafe loyalty list, conducted by the marketing team, showed that they consider three kinds of alternative. The first is national specialty subscription services that curate beans from many roasters and ship on a schedule. The second is supermarket premium espresso blends, bought because they are convenient. The third is buying bags directly from the cafes of local roasters, including Northfield itself. Pods and instant coffee were not mentioned; buyers who have invested in an espresso machine and grinder do not consider them substitutes. Kotler and Keller (2016) describe competitors as firms that satisfy the same customer need, which is why the rival set must come from the buyer's view rather than the industry directory.
Dimensions Drawn From the Segment
The interviews also showed what the segment values. Three dimensions came up repeatedly: freshness, meaning the days between roasting and arrival; dialing-in support, meaning help adjusting grind and dose to a new coffee; and variety, meaning how often the coffee changes. Price mattered less than expected; most interviewees already spent 20 to 30 dollars per bag.
| Rival | Freshness | Dialing-in support | Variety |
|---|---|---|---|
| National curated subscription | Moderate (7 to 14 days) | Low | High |
| Supermarket premium blend | Low (weeks to months) | None | Low |
| Local cafe purchase | High | Moderate (ask the barista) | Moderate |
| Northfield subscription (planned) | High (2 to 4 days) | High | Moderate |
The dimensions came from the buyers' own words, which means the position is built on what they already care about rather than on what the roaster wishes they cared about.
The Position Concedes Something
Northfield's position is: the freshest espresso delivered, with help to dial in every bag. The position concedes variety. Northfield roasts its own coffees and cannot match the dozens of roasters a curated service offers. Ries and Trout (2001) argue that a position must occupy a clear, simple place in the buyer's mind, and that trying to claim everything leaves a brand with no distinct place. Conceding variety lets Northfield own freshness and support, where national services are weak and local cafe purchases lack convenience. The concession is deliberate. A subscriber who wants a new roaster every month is better served elsewhere, and trying to win that buyer would require buying beans from other roasters, which would undermine the freshness claim.
Each Mix Element Traced Back
Each element of the marketing mix was checked against the position. Product: two rotating single-origin espressos and one house blend, roasted to order each Monday and Thursday. Each bag includes a card with a starting recipe (dose, yield, time) for common machines. This supports both freshness and dialing-in support. Price: 24 dollars per 12-ounce bag, shipping included, with a two-bag minimum per shipment. This is near the top of what interviewees already spent, which fits a premium position and does not compete with supermarket blends on price. Place: shipped only within two-day ground delivery range, covering about 300 miles from the roastery. Limiting the area protects the freshness promise. Promotion: short videos showing how to dial in each new coffee, shared by email the day it ships, plus a monthly live question session with Northfield's head barista. Promotion does the work of the dialing-in claim rather than simply announcing it.
Contradictions Resolved
The first draft of the plan contained three contradictions. First, it proposed national shipping to grow the subscriber base, which contradicted the freshness promise because deliveries beyond two days would arrive a week after roasting. The plan now limits shipping to the two-day zone and will add regional roasting only if demand justifies it. Second, it proposed a 15% discount for first-time subscribers, which risked training buyers to see the product as discount coffee. The discount was replaced with a free consultation call with a barista, which reinforces the support claim. Third, it proposed adding third-party roasters to increase variety, which contradicted the concession. That idea was dropped, and the team agreed to revisit it only if subscriber surveys show variety has become a reason for canceling. Resolving contradictions is where a positioning plan becomes real, because each one exposes a decision that would have weakened the position quietly.
How the Position Will Be Communicated
A position only works if buyers can repeat it. Northfield's shorthand is roasted Monday, in your grinder by Wednesday, with a recipe on the card. Every piece of communication, from the website header to the shipping box, carries a roast date in large print and a link to that coffee's dialing-in video. Cafe staff will mention the subscription when regular customers buy beans, since those customers already trust Northfield's freshness and are the most likely early subscribers. The message avoids claims about variety or about being the best coffee in the region, both of which the position has deliberately given up or cannot prove. Keeping every message on freshness and support repeats the same idea often enough for the segment to remember it.
Risks to the Position
The main risk is that national services improve their freshness by roasting closer to customers. Northfield's defense is the dialing-in support, which is harder to copy because it depends on staff knowledge. A second risk is that the two-day zone is too small to reach enough subscribers; the target is 1,200 subscribers in the first year, based on the size of the cafe loyalty list and regional espresso machine ownership, an estimate the team will revisit at six months.
Conclusion
Northfield's subscription is positioned on freshness and dialing-in support against the rivals home espresso drinkers actually consider. The position concedes variety on purpose, each mix element supports the position, and contradictions in the first draft were resolved in favor of the position rather than short-term growth.
References
Kotler, P., & Keller, K. L. (2016). Marketing management (15th ed.). Pearson.
Ries, A., & Trout, J. (2001). Positioning: The battle for your mind (20th anniversary ed.). McGraw-Hill.
Reading the MBA-FPX5012 Assessment 2 instructions
Assessment 2 in MBA FPX 5012 has you position a product for a target segment and defend the marketing mix that supports it. You identify the competitors the segment actually compares, choose dimensions that matter to that segment, map the position, state what the position gives up, show how product, price, place and promotion each support the position, resolve any conflicts among them, plan communication and identify risks. The segment from Assessment 1 or a similar one provides the focus. Marketing strategy texts on positioning, such as the work of Al Ries and Jack Trout, support the defense.
How the MBA-FPX5012 Assessment 2 example is put together
Competitors, dimensions, position, mix. The opening carries forward the target segment from the first assessment. A competitor block names the rivals this segment actually considers, which is frequently not the obvious market leader. A dimensions block establishes what this segment weighs when choosing, from evidence rather than from assumption. A position block places the firm on those dimensions and states plainly what it concedes. A mix block then derives each element from the position, showing the trace. A coherence block reads the four together and resolves any element pulling against the others. The closing names what would force the position to change, such as a competitor move or a shift in what the segment values. Competitor claims carry evidence rather than assertion throughout.
MBA FPX 5012 Assessment 2 scoring guide: what Distinguished looks like
The scoring guide weighs the competitive set, the dimensions, the position, the concession, the mix alignment and the risks. The competitive set reaches Distinguished when drawn from what buyers compare, such as café visits and pod machines, not only other roasters. Dimensions score higher when they come from the segment's priorities. The position earns credit when it concedes something, like convenience for freshness. Mix alignment is judged on whether every element traces to the position. Contradictions, such as a premium position with deep discounts, should be resolved. Communication should be planned, with one message the segment will remember. Risks should be specific, such as a large chain launching a cheaper fresh-roast service. Distinguished defenses show a coherent mix.
Common MBA FPX 5012 Assessment 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Positioning papers often compare the product only with direct competitors, missing the substitutes buyers actually weigh. Another weakness is claiming to be best on every dimension, which is not a position. The mix is described element by element without linking each to the position. Contradictions go unnoticed, like a luxury brand sold through discount channels. Communication is generic. Risks are left out, including how rivals might respond. Drawing a simple map of the competitive set on two dimensions the segment cares about, then checking each mix element against the chosen spot, keeps the defense coherent and prepares the marketing synthesis in Assessment 3.
Get a MBA FPX 5012 Assessment 2 example written to your instructions
Send the Assessment 2 instructions and your MBA FPX 5012 scoring guide, along with the segmentation your first assessment produced. We write a custom example against those criteria and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first custom sample is free, and stating what the position gives up is the move most papers never make. The paper above is an original model document written by our desk, not a submitted student paper and not an official Capella University document.
More MBA FPX 5012 papers and MBA samples
- MBA FPX 5012 Assessment 1: Segmentation and Targeting
- MBA FPX 5012 Assessment 3: Marketing Synthesis
- MBA FPX 5014 Assessment 2: Evaluation of Capital Projects
- MBA FPX 5010 Assessment 2: Costing and Budget Decision
- MBA FPX 5016 Assessment 2: Costed Improvement Case
- MBA FPX 5008 Assessment 2: Costed Recommendation From Data
MBA FPX 5012 Assessment 2 questions, answered
How do I choose positioning dimensions?
From what the target segment weighs, established with evidence where you can get it. Reviews, published research, what competitors emphasize in their own communication and what buyers complain about all indicate it. Dimensions chosen because a framework lists them frequently turn out to be ones nobody buys on.
Does the position have to concede something?
In practice yes, and saying so is what makes it credible. Resources spent being excellent at one thing are resources not spent elsewhere, and a reader knows that. A position naming its own trade reads as a decision, while one claiming universal superiority reads as marketing copy.
What if the mix contradicts the position?
Then something has to change and the paper should show which. A premium position with a discount channel is the classic case. Resolving it explicitly, and saying what you gave up to resolve it, demonstrates the coherence the criteria are reading for far better than a mix presented as though it never conflicted.
Where can I find a free MBA FPX 5012 Assessment 2 sample paper?
This page contains the complete positioning defense for the espresso subscription, with the rivals buyers consider, dimensions drawn from the segment, a position that concedes something and each mix element traced back.
Does the position have to concede something in MBA FPX 5012 Assessment 2?
Yes. A position that claims every advantage is not credible. Giving something up, such as speed or low price, makes the chosen strength believable.